Severin

I entered the market when these dropped below $1,000 (watched them for a year starting at $2,500!).

Picked up a Pioneer DVR-520H-s with 80GB drive (DVR-720H-s same and has 160GB).

Link to Pioneer's archive <http://www.pioneer.com.au/ home_entertainment/archive.html> (The DVR-510H-s on this page pre- dates the 520/720 and also has DV OUT).

Reason for picking the 520/720 (other than price) was the DV OUT facility, it can be connected to the Mac and imports to iMovie via firewire. It acts as if it is a video camera (not an external hard disk).

Important - it was the only model range readily available with DV OUT making importing into iMovie easy.

Unfortunately it has been replaced by a model with DV IN and no DV OUT (DVR-530H / DVR-630H <http://www.pioneer.com.au/ home_entertainment/dvdplayersandrecorders/index.html>). I've kept an eye on the market and have not yet seen another model / range with DV OUT. Could not find 510/520/720 models on eBay.

DVD HDD units typically record in MPEG2 format and create video format disks (either video or VR formats) for use in DVD players, not data format disks for importing into iMovie.

Therefore you'll need to:
- find another model with DV OUT
or
- rip the DVD's to your disk and convert to a format that iMovie can handle (DV, DV Widescreen, HDV1080i, HDV720p, MPEG-4, iSight)

On the Superdrive formats, check System Profiler.app, and firmware updates.

Hope this helps.

Paul

On 16/06/2006, at 5:21 PM, Severin Crisp wrote:

Due to the karking of a VCR I am looking to buy a DVD HDD recorder. One requirement is to record off air for subsequent importation into iMovie. Currently I have been doing this by recording to VHS, playing back into my camera and then transferring into the computer. I envisage transferring via DVD in future. Format of DVDs is my query. Am I correct in the supposition that DVD+R or DVD+RW is not compatible with my Superdrive? Further, if anyone has words of wisdom on this area it would be most appreciated. I should mention that I already have a combo DVD player/VHS recorder so I do not need VHS tape facility, which I will phase out of my operation now.
Severin Crisp

Thank you

Paul van der Mey
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Mob. 0419 201 477