> http://www.opensolaris.org/os/project/website/wiki_requirements/

> E3 The software must be Java based
> 
> In order that the wiki software can be extended and maintained, given the 
> infrastructure resources, the most sensible choice of technology on which to 
> base the software is Java.


This requirement seems out of place here.  In particular, I believe it will tend
to drive the decision away from proven, high quality wikis like mediawiki 
towards
fringe offerings whose primary attribute is being written in Java.

Personally, I'd rather trade off a slightly higher cost of maintenance for
the huge usability, familiarity, stability and worldwide usage of mediawiki.

PHP, Ruby, Python and Perl are all great web-development languages; there is no
reason why we must be Java-only by policy.  "Java" may well be a "plus" in the
evaluation, and I have no issues with it being a conditional or optional
requirement.  But it certainly isn't essential.


   -John




_______________________________________________
website-discuss mailing list
[email protected]

Reply via email to