Hi,

On 12/09/2016 05:25 PM, Pine W wrote:
> While I appreciate the attempt to be funny, I am not amused in this case.
> Surprise UI changes could, for example, result in thousands of dollars'
> worth of instructional videos becoming instantly out of sync with the
> real-world user experience. Also, users who may have spent considerable
> time perfecting their templates may be surprised to find that they need to
> make changes to keep the templates in sync with other changes to the UI.
> The problem isn't so much that the UI was changed, as that it was changed
> without notice and consultation. This isn't funny.

Well, I was specifically responding to Strainu's comment that "No change
is to small to be disliked by one or more people!" which seemed to be in
jest too.

But I think you're significantly over-exaggerating the costs of this UI
change, and changes in general. MediaWiki's UI changes literally every
day when localization messages are updated, reworded, or added. Special
pages are re-organized to be made more intuitive, toolbars re-arranged,
etc. If you're making instructional videos, colors *barely* changing
seem like the least of your problems in terms of becoming out of date.
The VisualEditor project has a script that automatically generates
localized screenshots of the user interface so the user manual stays up
to date, I don't know if any solution has been worked out for videos yet.

-- Legoktm

_______________________________________________
Wikitech-l mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikitech-l

Reply via email to