Am 03/20/17 um 01:11 schrieb Stephen Connolly: > On Sun 19 Mar 2017 at 12:13, Stephen Connolly < > stephen.alan.conno...@gmail.com> wrote: > >> We need to define: >> >> * what is a bug vs what is an rfe >> >> * what are the different severities for bugs and rfes >> > > S1: software is unusable, halts, crashes, or is inaccessible, resulting in > a critical impact on the operation. No workaround is available > > Examples: > > Maven crashes on OS-X > Maven goes into infinite loop when installing war artifacts > > S2: software operates but due to an error, its operation is severely > restricted. No workaround is available > > Examples: > > Maven deploys invalid/corrupt artifacts > Maven silently skips tests without asking > Maven ignores batch mode and auto-version submosules for a reactor with > more than 20 modules to release > > S3: software operates with limitations due to an error that is not critical > to the overall operation. For example, a workaround forces a user to use a > time-consuming procedure to operate the software, or removes a > non-essential feature. > > Examples: > > Maven has started to prompt with Y/N for each test to be run when > -DconfirmTests=false or when in batch mode. > Maven is stuck logging at debug level > > S4: software can be used with only slight inconvenience. > > Examples: > > Maven colour logging is broken. > Maven is prompting to start execution at the start of the reactor when not > in batch mode > > Wdyt
Based on that, what severity would be assigned to the following issues? This somehow lacks the "changes incorrect/unexpected/broken behaviour" category we hopefully do not have to use that often. Some real-world examples we can use to sort things out. Bugs: ----- MRESOLVER-8 MRESOLVER-9 MNG-5359 MNG-5984 MNG-6114 MNG-6164 MNG-5227 (ModelBuilder part only - resolver does it since years) MNG-5935 MNG-6135 (bug we discussed to death already) RFEs: ----- MNG-4463 (or bug due to lack of support?) MNG-5527 (or bug due to lack of support?) MNG-5600 (or bug due to lack of support?) MNG-5971 (currently a new scope - include) MNG-5761+MRESOLVER-10 (or bug - current behaviour unexpected/inconsistent with site) Regards, -- Christian --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscr...@maven.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: dev-h...@maven.apache.org
