Sorry if this is somewhat off topic. Perhaps it's not since it involves
Linux and NAT. I have many friends using "Broadband Routers" that I've
set up. As I imagine we all know these allow one machine to act like a proxy
for a group of other machines. (Yes, I know it's technically not a proxy
and that it uses NAT. I'm speaking in concepts. Hey, for that matter it's
not really a Router.)
With the Comcast acquisition of ATTBI there is a "Transition Wizard". They
say it must be applied by the end of the month. Using that requires signing
a new Subscriber Agreement. Section 6, subsection g of this states:
Theft of Service. You will not connect the Service or any Comcast
Equipment to more computers, either on or outside of the Premises, than are
reflected in your account with us. You acknowledge that any unauthorized
receipt of the Service constitutes theft of service, which is a violation
of federal law and can result in both civil and criminal penalties. In addition,
if the violations are willful and for commercial advantage or private financial
gain, the penalties may be increased.
Now, technically no one is connecting any additional machines to the "Service"
just to the machine which is making Internet requests on their behalf. Also,
and I know the laws are really flakey in this area, but wouldn't intercepting,
decoding and reading my traffic be a breach of my privacy as well as a violation
of the reverse engineering laws?
One of my friends is a bit concerned so I wrote a note to Comcast, requesting
a clarification of the passage, particularly as it applies to "Broadband
Routers". I included questions on privacy and packet disassembly and tried
to keep it very polite. I suspect that this is pretty much business as usual
but wanted to hear about the issues from the experts.
I appreciate any feedback or suggestions. Thanks, GGK
- Re: OT- Comcast Subscriber Agreement Greg Kettmann
- Re: OT- Comcast Subscriber Agreement Michael O'Donnell
- Re: OT- Comcast Subscriber Agreement Jeff Kinz
- Re: OT- Comcast Subscriber Agreement Jerry Feldman
- Re: OT- Comcast Subscriber Agreement bscott
- Re: OT- Comcast Subscriber Agreement Chris
- Re: OT- Comcast Subscriber Agreement R. Sean Hartnett
- Re: OT- Comcast Subscriber Agreement Michael O'Donnell
- Re: OT- Comcast Subscriber Agreement Chris
- Re: OT- Comcast Subscriber Agreeme... Michael O'Donnell
- Re: OT- Comcast Subscriber Agreement Andrew W. Gaunt