Re: One official build system?

[Kornel Benko]

Am Dienstag, 14. Juni 2016 um 14:56:21, schrieb Scott Kostyshak 
<skost...@lyx.org>
> On Tue, Jun 14, 2016 at 10:02:23AM +0200, Kornel Benko wrote:
> > Am Montag, 13. Juni 2016 um 19:09:04, schrieb Scott Kostyshak 
> > <skost...@lyx.org>
> > > Note also that for me make package_source produces a tar.gz, not a
> > > tar.xz as you suggested above.
> > 
> > It depends on how you configure, so that 'make package' knows what to 
> > produce.
> > 1.)  -DCPACK_SOURCE_TGZ:BOOL=ON
> >     -> .tar.gz
> > 2.)  -DCPACK_SOURCE_TBZ2:BOOL=ON
> >     -> .bz2
> > 3.) -DCPACK_SOURCE_TZ:BOOL=ON
> >     -> .tar.Z
> > or
> > 4.)  -DCPACK_SOURCE_ZIP:BOOL=ON
> >     -> nothing on linux
> > 
> > (Select only one of them)
> > But, yes, .tar.xz is not created :(
> 
> OK
> 
> > For the differences:
> >     'make git-archive' and 'make package_source' create different files.
> > Which one have you used for comparison?
> 
> I used make package_source.
> 
> > Here, 'make package_source' creates
> >     LyX-2.3.tar.gz
> >     LyX-2.3.tar.xz
> >     LyX-2.3.tar.Z
> 
> Ah so xz is created? I must have missed that.
> 
> If you have time and want to take a look, compare the tar.gz you get
> from CMake to the 2.2.0 tar from the following command:
> yourself: ./autogen.sh && ./configure && make lyxdist

I made it. But I do not see many differences.
To test:
        # cd  /usr/BUILD/BuildLyxGitQt5.6mainAutomake
        # make lyxdist
        # cd /usr/BUILD/BuildLyxGitQt5.6main-gcc5.3
        # make package_source
        # cd ~/tmp
        # mkdir -p compare/automake
        # cd compare/automake
        # tar axvf /usr/BUILD/BuildLyxGitQt5.6mainAutomake/lyx-2.3.0dev.tar.gz
        # cd ~/tmp
        # mkdir -p compare/cmake
        # cd compare/cmake
        # tar axvf /usr/BUILD/BuildLyxGitQt5.6main-gcc5.3/LyX-2.3.tar.gz
        # cd LyX-2.3
        # diff -r .  ~/tmp/compare/automake/lyx-2.3.0dev/.

The result is that cmake part misses
        Makefile.in
automake misses
        lib/fonts/*.sfd (11 files)
        lib/images/ipa/*.svgz (30 files)
        lib/images/oxygen/*.svgz (88 files)
        src/mathed/InsetMathXYArrow.{cpp,h}
        3rdparty/boost/libs/regex/src/{icu,usinstances,wc_regex_traits}.cpp

There are also many files in cmake-tar which are only for tests and not 
important.
But the automake missed files are more than serious IMHO.

        Kornel

signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part.