Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-12 Thread Indi
On Sat, Dec 10, 2011 at 03:40:02PM +0100, Pandu Poluan wrote:
On Dec 10, 2011 8:50 PM, LinuxIsOne [1]linuxis...@gmail.com wrote:

 
- 8 snip
 
 
  I have come to conclusion that almost all Linux work almost in the
  same way since they have the same kernel, however, this is what I
  think.
 
I don't mean to scare you, but most Linux distros work differently.
 
First, there might be differences in how they install a package.
There's RPM, apt, pacman, portage, and others.
 
Second, there are differences in the init system. Gentoo users
OpenRC, Ubuntu uses upstart, and others use SysVinit, systemd, and so
on.
 
And even you can't guarantee that the kernels are the same. Many
distros introduce their own distro-specific patches to the vanilla
kernel. With Gentoo, it's even more complicated, as most experienced
Gentooroids will configure and compile their own kernels.
 
(The last paragraph, however, is the reason why Gentoo is so secure:
attackers can't be sure that the vuln they're targeting is located at
the right spot, *if* the vuln exists at all. Throw in hardened patches
like GrSecurity, PAX, and SELinux... well, you get the idea.)

Probably he doesn't; one has to learn a bit before any of this will
make sense to them. Imagine having this converstaion with your
great-aunt Agnes... ;)

 
((No wonder NASDAQ uses Gentoo for its infrastructure))
 

Indeed.

-- 
♫ ❤ ♫ ❤ ♫ ❤ ♫ ❤ 




Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-12 Thread James Broadhead
On 12 December 2011 23:52, Indi thebeelzebubtrig...@gmail.com wrote:
 On Sat, Dec 10, 2011 at 03:40:02PM +0100, Pandu Poluan wrote:
    On Dec 10, 2011 8:50 PM, LinuxIsOne [1]linuxis...@gmail.com wrote:

    ((No wonder NASDAQ uses Gentoo for its infrastructure))


 Indeed

What a bunch of ricers :P



Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-12 Thread Indi
On Tue, Dec 13, 2011 at 01:10:02AM +0100, James Broadhead wrote:
 On 12 December 2011 23:52, Indi thebeelzebubtrig...@gmail.com wrote:
  On Sat, Dec 10, 2011 at 03:40:02PM +0100, Pandu Poluan wrote:
     On Dec 10, 2011 8:50 PM, LinuxIsOne [1]linuxis...@gmail.com wrote:
 
     ((No wonder NASDAQ uses Gentoo for its infrastructure))
 
 
  Indeed
 
 What a bunch of ricers :P

I LOL'd. :)

-- 
caveat utilitor
♫ ❤ ♫ ❤ ♫ ❤ ♫ ❤ 



Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-12 Thread Pandu Poluan
On Dec 13, 2011 7:09 AM, James Broadhead jamesbroadh...@gmail.com wrote:

 On 12 December 2011 23:52, Indi thebeelzebubtrig...@gmail.com wrote:
  On Sat, Dec 10, 2011 at 03:40:02PM +0100, Pandu Poluan wrote:
 On Dec 10, 2011 8:50 PM, LinuxIsOne [1]linuxis...@gmail.com
wrote:
 
 ((No wonder NASDAQ uses Gentoo for its infrastructure))
 
 
  Indeed

 What a bunch of ricers :P


I'm sure they are. In the interview [1], Lameter said that quote NASDAQ
uses a modified version of the Gentoo Linux distribution. /quote

modified version? That practically screams ricers! to me :-D

[1]
http://m.itworld.com/open-source/193823/how-linux-mastered-wall-street?mm_ref=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.gossamer-threads.com%2Flists%2Fgentoo%2Fuser%2F236472

Rgds,


Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-10 Thread Sebastian Beßler
On 08.12.2011 17:11, LinuxIsOne wrote:

 Ah, thanks for the nice suggestions, I would keep a note of it. I
 would install in one old machine, 

You could use virtualbox to create a virtual PC and install Gentoo
there. That would eliminate the required space for a second monitor,
keyboard and mouse.

Virtualbox is mostly self-explaining so that should not be so much of a
problem.

Greetings

Sebastian Beßler



signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature


Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-10 Thread LinuxIsOne
On Thu, Dec 8, 2011 at 5:11 PM, Frank Steinmetzger war...@gmx.de wrote:


 I did this in the past. But recently I’m reassessing this, with Ubuntu
 changing
 the default look and the way it works with every other release (remember
 the
 hassle about window buttons to the left by default?). I can’t really
 explain
 -- let alone justify -- to a newbie, who had to adapt from Win to Ubuntu
 that
 he has to do so again, whether he wants to or not. Plus it seems to me they
 are trying to become Apple in the Linux world, with own services (and
 design).
 I am totally at a loss with entry-level distros right now.

 I tried Mint, also the new one with Gnome 3. The praised Mint menu seems
 overloaded to me (it shows too much at once IMHO). I somehow dislike custom
 layers over a standard interface, much like, if I bought an HTC Android, I
 would reflash it without Sense UI, but I’m digressing.

 OpenSuse seems even more overloaded. Albeit it provides a whole
 environment,
 Yast was full of stuff a simple user will never need. It also caused a very
 long and voluminous installation process.
 I must add though that I peeked into both Mint and Suse only for a day or
 so,
 without ever using it myself, so I don’t know jack about update procedures.

 A friend of mine wanted Linux, so I installed Debian stable for her with
 KDE
 4.4. It’s not bleeding edge, but it works because it doesn’t change much
 (hence
 keeps working) and because she doesn’t do a lot of fancy stuff. (And also
 because I used Debian testing for a while, so I know a bit about how to do
 some
 helpdesking).


I have come to conclusion that almost all Linux work almost in the same way
since they have the same kernel, however, this is what I think.


Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-10 Thread LinuxIsOne
On Sat, Dec 10, 2011 at 8:31 AM, Sebastian Beßler
sebast...@darkmetatron.de wrote:

 Virtualbox is mostly self-explaining so that should not be so much of a
 problem.

VB works from within another OS or needs memory of HDD?



Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-10 Thread Pandu Poluan
On Dec 10, 2011 8:50 PM, LinuxIsOne linuxis...@gmail.com wrote:


- 8 snip


 I have come to conclusion that almost all Linux work almost in the same
way since they have the same kernel, however, this is what I think.

I don't mean to scare you, but most Linux distros work differently.

First, there might be differences in how they install a package. There's
RPM, apt, pacman, portage, and others.

Second, there are differences in the init system. Gentoo users OpenRC,
Ubuntu uses upstart, and others use SysVinit, systemd, and so on.

And even you can't guarantee that the kernels are the same. Many distros
introduce their own distro-specific patches to the vanilla kernel. With
Gentoo, it's even more complicated, as most experienced Gentooroids will
configure and compile their own kernels.

(The last paragraph, however, is the reason why Gentoo is so secure:
attackers can't be sure that the vuln they're targeting is located at the
right spot, *if* the vuln exists at all. Throw in hardened patches like
GrSecurity, PAX, and SELinux... well, you get the idea.)

((No wonder NASDAQ uses Gentoo for its infrastructure))

Rgds,


Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-10 Thread LinuxIsOne
On Sat, Dec 10, 2011 at 9:32 AM, Pandu Poluan pa...@poluan.info wrote:

 I don't mean to scare you, but most Linux distros work differently.

 First, there might be differences in how they install a package. There's
 RPM, apt, pacman, portage, and others.

 Second, there are differences in the init system. Gentoo users OpenRC,
 Ubuntu uses upstart, and others use SysVinit, systemd, and so on.

init system? I am first time hearing this, may be, I would read it
later or sometimes about what is it

 And even you can't guarantee that the kernels are the same. Many distros
 introduce their own distro-specific patches to the vanilla kernel. With
 Gentoo, it's even more complicated, as most experienced Gentooroids will
 configure and compile their own kernels.

 (The last paragraph, however, is the reason why Gentoo is so secure:
 attackers can't be sure that the vuln they're targeting is located at the
 right spot, *if* the vuln exists at all. Throw in hardened patches like
 GrSecurity, PAX, and SELinux... well, you get the idea.)

Oh I see. Thanks for clarification Pandu.

 ((No wonder NASDAQ uses Gentoo for its infrastructure))

Great to hear.



Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-10 Thread Alan McKinnon
On Sat, 10 Dec 2011 08:46:16 -0500
LinuxIsOne linuxis...@gmail.com wrote:

 On Thu, Dec 8, 2011 at 5:11 PM, Frank Steinmetzger war...@gmx.de
 wrote:
 
 
  I did this in the past. But recently I’m reassessing this, with
  Ubuntu changing
  the default look and the way it works with every other release
  (remember the
  hassle about window buttons to the left by default?). I can’t really
  explain
  -- let alone justify -- to a newbie, who had to adapt from Win to
  Ubuntu that
  he has to do so again, whether he wants to or not. Plus it seems to
  me they are trying to become Apple in the Linux world, with own
  services (and design).
  I am totally at a loss with entry-level distros right now.
 
  I tried Mint, also the new one with Gnome 3. The praised Mint menu
  seems overloaded to me (it shows too much at once IMHO). I somehow
  dislike custom layers over a standard interface, much like, if I
  bought an HTC Android, I would reflash it without Sense UI, but I’m
  digressing.
 
  OpenSuse seems even more overloaded. Albeit it provides a whole
  environment,
  Yast was full of stuff a simple user will never need. It also
  caused a very long and voluminous installation process.
  I must add though that I peeked into both Mint and Suse only for a
  day or so,
  without ever using it myself, so I don’t know jack about update
  procedures.
 
  A friend of mine wanted Linux, so I installed Debian stable for her
  with KDE
  4.4. It’s not bleeding edge, but it works because it doesn’t change
  much (hence
  keeps working) and because she doesn’t do a lot of fancy stuff.
  (And also because I used Debian testing for a while, so I know a
  bit about how to do some
  helpdesking).
 
 
 I have come to conclusion that almost all Linux work almost in the
 same way since they have the same kernel, however, this is what I
 think.


Not quite.

A very small selection of all possible Unixes work the same.
Ubuntu and Debian are quite similar as they have common roots.
RedHat works rather like an old Fedora (and to some degree that's almost
exactly what it is).
Gentoo looks and feels like whatever you decide to make it to be
(because it is so highly configurable and adaptable)

The fact is that the kernel make very little difference to how the
overall system works. YOU do not interact with the kernel, YOU interact
with a collection of programs called userland, and these things can
all be very different. For example, I'm looking at three computers
right now that all run Linux, and they are all very very different:

- this laptop, which is set up as a traditional Unix with X,
- my phone running Android 
- my wireless router/modem which runs busybox

Be careful of making rash conclusions about Linux. A Linux system is not
like anything particularly, it is whatever the person who built it
decided it should be.

What you will find is that desktop Linuxes share many common elements.
This is not surprising - all versions of Windows share many common
elements too.

-- 
Alan McKinnnon
alan.mckin...@gmail.com



Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-10 Thread Alan McKinnon
On Sat, 10 Dec 2011 08:47:47 -0500
LinuxIsOne linuxis...@gmail.com wrote:

 On Sat, Dec 10, 2011 at 8:31 AM, Sebastian Beßler
 sebast...@darkmetatron.de wrote:
 
  Virtualbox is mostly self-explaining so that should not be so much
  of a problem.
 
 VB works from within another OS or needs memory of HDD?
 

VirtualBox is a program that runs on a working system with a
functioning OS. Like all programs it needs resources like memory and
hard disk space. Unlike most programs it usually uses a LOT of memory
and hard disk space to be useful.

-- 
Alan McKinnnon
alan.mckin...@gmail.com



Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-10 Thread LinuxIsOne
On Sat, Dec 10, 2011 at 11:51 AM, Alan McKinnon alan.mckin...@gmail.com wrote:

 A very small selection of all possible Unixes work the same.
 Ubuntu and Debian are quite similar as they have common roots.
 RedHat works rather like an old Fedora (and to some degree that's almost
 exactly what it is).
 Gentoo looks and feels like whatever you decide to make it to be
 (because it is so highly configurable and adaptable)

 The fact is that the kernel make very little difference to how the
 overall system works. YOU do not interact with the kernel, YOU interact
 with a collection of programs called userland, and these things can
 all be very different. For example, I'm looking at three computers
 right now that all run Linux, and they are all very very different:

 - this laptop, which is set up as a traditional Unix with X,
 - my phone running Android
 - my wireless router/modem which runs busybox

 Be careful of making rash conclusions about Linux. A Linux system is not
 like anything particularly, it is whatever the person who built it
 decided it should be.

 What you will find is that desktop Linuxes share many common elements.
 This is not surprising - all versions of Windows share many common
 elements too.

Thanks for this explanation. I earlier (before this post) used to
think that it is the kernel which is a deciding factor..., but yes it
is correct to say NO for this. Linux is really highly configurable at
least for this reason is a better choice and especially Gentoo - which
could be made to work like anything we wish (as you say)  --- really
great to know. ON one of the machine and in the time to come, I wold
first read how to install Gentoo and then would definitely (100%) try
to install Gentooo  at least a successful installation would make
me know many things as far as Gentoo is considered.. Eventually I
would come to these great mailing lists for the help, but since I am
in another job, so it would take much time, but I would try

Thanks.



Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-10 Thread LinuxIsOne
On Sat, Dec 10, 2011 at 11:53 AM, Alan McKinnon alan.mckin...@gmail.com wrote:

 VirtualBox is a program that runs on a working system with a
 functioning OS. Like all programs it needs resources like memory and
 hard disk space. Unlike most programs it usually uses a LOT of memory
 and hard disk space to be useful.

Oh I see. I see VB in Ubuntu...(how to) since right now I have Ubuntu.



Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-09 Thread Claudio Roberto França Pereira
Wait a minute, an actual doctor installed and maintain Gentoo boxes?



Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-09 Thread Frank Steinmetzger
On Sat, Dec 10, 2011 at 01:02:14AM -0200, Claudio Roberto França Pereira wrote:
 Wait a minute, an actual doctor installed and maintain Gentoo boxes?

??
-- 
Gruß | Greetings | Qapla'
I forbid any use of my email addresses with Facebook services.

A hammer is a wonderful tool,
but it is plain unsuitable for cleaning windows.  (SelfHTML forum)


pgpFBwYCUkesc.pgp
Description: PGP signature


Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-09 Thread Claudio Roberto França Pereira
By Lorenzo Badieri:
[...] My high school was centered around
humanities/classical studies: ancient greek, latin, philosophy; after
high school, I managed to get into MED SCHOOL. So, no computer
science/informatics at all. However, I was really curios about
computers, and I messed up my family's desktop pc a couple of times :) [...]



Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-08 Thread James Broadhead
On 8 December 2011 06:57, LinuxIsOne linuxis...@gmail.com wrote:
 On Wed, Dec 7, 2011 at 5:20 AM, Stroller strol...@stellar.eclipse.co.uk 
 wrote:

 I tried Ubuntu, hated this *so* much.

 I'm sure all the respondents were just trying to be helpful, but they made 
 Ubuntu look like the distro of idiots.

 How do you say like this? Can you give me an example please?


The next time you have a problem with anything related to linux,
follow a link to an Ubuntu user forum. Unfortunately, the quality of
advice on them tends to be pretty low. :-(



Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-08 Thread LinuxIsOne
On Thu, Dec 8, 2011 at 5:58 AM, James Broadhead
jamesbroadh...@gmail.com wrote:

 The next time you have a problem with anything related to linux,
 follow a link to an Ubuntu user forum. Unfortunately, the quality of
 advice on them tends to be pretty low. :-(

Really?



Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-08 Thread Alan McKinnon
On Thu, 8 Dec 2011 08:55:48 -0500
LinuxIsOne linuxis...@gmail.com wrote:

 On Thu, Dec 8, 2011 at 5:58 AM, James Broadhead
 jamesbroadh...@gmail.com wrote:
 
  The next time you have a problem with anything related to linux,
  follow a link to an Ubuntu user forum. Unfortunately, the quality of
  advice on them tends to be pretty low. :-(
 
 Really?
 

Don't take our word for it, go look for yourself.

I could give you examples of how that forum works, I could give you
links that show what we are saying, but NOTHING can prepare you for
what you really find on the Ubuntu user forums.

Like I said, just go there and have a look for yourself.

-- 
Alan McKinnnon
alan.mckin...@gmail.com



Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-08 Thread LinuxIsOne
On Thu, Dec 8, 2011 at 9:29 AM, Alan McKinnon alan.mckin...@gmail.com wrote:

 Don't take our word for it, go look for yourself.

 I could give you examples of how that forum works, I could give you
 links that show what we are saying, but NOTHING can prepare you for
 what you really find on the Ubuntu user forums.

Okay but at least Ubuntu is good for new users and Windows convert and
for those doesn't it give a learning curve in Linux?



Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-08 Thread James Broadhead
On 8 December 2011 15:10, LinuxIsOne linuxis...@gmail.com wrote:
 On Thu, Dec 8, 2011 at 9:29 AM, Alan McKinnon alan.mckin...@gmail.com wrote:

 Don't take our word for it, go look for yourself.

 I could give you examples of how that forum works, I could give you
 links that show what we are saying, but NOTHING can prepare you for
 what you really find on the Ubuntu user forums.

 Okay but at least Ubuntu is good for new users and Windows convert and
 for those doesn't it give a learning curve in Linux?

That's debatable; it generally means that the amount of time that
passes before they realise that Linux is not Windows is increased. It
definitely gets them booted into a desktop environment quicker, but it
doesn't really save on the learning curve - something will go awry
sooner or later, and the fact that they've had the command-line hidden
from them until that first fateful trip to the forums won't feel like
such a benefit then.



Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-08 Thread LinuxIsOne
On Thu, Dec 8, 2011 at 10:18 AM, James Broadhead
jamesbroadh...@gmail.com wrote:

 That's debatable; it generally means that the amount of time that
 passes before they realise that Linux is not Windows is increased. It
 definitely gets them booted into a desktop environment quicker, but it
 doesn't really save on the learning curve - something will go awry
 sooner or later, and the fact that they've had the command-line hidden
 from them until that first fateful trip to the forums won't feel like
 such a benefit then.

Ok, I agree with you but I have just installed since I had to Linux
experience but everything is working like a charm. I don't know if any
problem would come.



Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-08 Thread LinuxIsOne
On Thu, Dec 8, 2011 at 10:35 AM, LinuxIsOne linuxis...@gmail.com wrote:

 That's debatable; it generally means that the amount of time that
 passes before they realise that Linux is not Windows is increased. It
 definitely gets them booted into a desktop environment quicker, but it
 doesn't really save on the learning curve - something will go awry
 sooner or later, and the fact that they've had the command-line hidden
 from them until that first fateful trip to the forums won't feel like
 such a benefit then.

 Ok, I agree with you but I have just installed since I had to Linux
 experience but everything is working like a charm. I don't know if any
 problem would come.

I mean i have no Linux experience and everything is working like a
charm in Ubuntu and yes you are correct to say that command line is
hidden which is the real gem in linux. I agree with you in this
regard. But I guess (not sure) if Ubuntu would give me the Linux
learning environment?



Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-08 Thread Michael Mol
On Thu, Dec 8, 2011 at 10:18 AM, James Broadhead
jamesbroadh...@gmail.com wrote:
 On 8 December 2011 15:10, LinuxIsOne linuxis...@gmail.com wrote:
 On Thu, Dec 8, 2011 at 9:29 AM, Alan McKinnon alan.mckin...@gmail.com 
 wrote:

 Don't take our word for it, go look for yourself.

 I could give you examples of how that forum works, I could give you
 links that show what we are saying, but NOTHING can prepare you for
 what you really find on the Ubuntu user forums.

 Okay but at least Ubuntu is good for new users and Windows convert and
 for those doesn't it give a learning curve in Linux?

 That's debatable; it generally means that the amount of time that
 passes before they realise that Linux is not Windows is increased. It
 definitely gets them booted into a desktop environment quicker, but it
 doesn't really save on the learning curve - something will go awry
 sooner or later, and the fact that they've had the command-line hidden
 from them until that first fateful trip to the forums won't feel like
 such a benefit then.


I got started with Linux via Red Hat 5.2. (Pre-Fedora, pre-RHEL days).
I used it for only a few days before switching to Debian. If I hadn't
seen Red Hat's relatively automagic setup of X, and the availability
of all the tools to do things I wanted using a GUI interface, I
probably would have hopped back to Windows 95.

As it was, seeing that GUI and knowing that a familiar interface was
what left me willing to deal with the couple weeks it took me to learn
how to set up XFree86 3.3.6 on Debian.[1] Fortunately, just about
every Linux distro, including Gentoo, has much better resource for
getting a GUI up and running, so a modern newbie experience shouldn't
be nearly so taxing on initial patience.

Sure, being able to learn a system inside and out is a good thing, but
you need to get past that initial hurdle before you're ready to tackle
it, and Ubuntu handles that initial hurdle quite well. Give a user six
months to a year, and they'll grow tired of Ubuntu constantly breaking
their customizations, and they'll probably switch to Debian or Linux
Mint. I've watched that leap several times now. A few of them
eventually leave Debian or Mint for Gentoo. Some land on Fedora or
OpenSuSE, but they're usually heavily working with RHEL or CentOS in
other contexts.

[1] Luckily, I wasn't even an adolescent yet; I don't think I'd have
had the time or patience for that as an adult.

-- 
:wq



Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-08 Thread Michael Mol
On Thu, Dec 8, 2011 at 10:36 AM, LinuxIsOne linuxis...@gmail.com wrote:
 On Thu, Dec 8, 2011 at 10:35 AM, LinuxIsOne linuxis...@gmail.com wrote:

 That's debatable; it generally means that the amount of time that
 passes before they realise that Linux is not Windows is increased. It
 definitely gets them booted into a desktop environment quicker, but it
 doesn't really save on the learning curve - something will go awry
 sooner or later, and the fact that they've had the command-line hidden
 from them until that first fateful trip to the forums won't feel like
 such a benefit then.

 Ok, I agree with you but I have just installed since I had to Linux
 experience but everything is working like a charm. I don't know if any
 problem would come.

 I mean i have no Linux experience and everything is working like a
 charm in Ubuntu and yes you are correct to say that command line is
 hidden which is the real gem in linux. I agree with you in this
 regard. But I guess (not sure) if Ubuntu would give me the Linux
 learning environment?

As long as we're talking about *you*, and not about someone you're
setting things up for, here's what I'd suggest:

1) Keep your existing Ubuntu setup operational, at least for a while.
Gentoo isn't something you should dive into unless you have a
fallback, at least until you learn enough to be able to fix the things
you'll encounter.
2) Set up Gentoo as a second machine; it really is a great way to
learn how a lot of the moving parts in Linux work.

Once you've got Gentoo doing everything you want it to do, and you've
burned yourself a couple times, you'll be in a good position to make a
decision for yourself. I've actually bounced back and forth between
Ubuntu and Gentoo twice in the last three or four years, but I think
I'm finally ready to go steady with Gentoo. :)

Ubuntu is great for it just works. Ubuntu isn't so great for it
just keeps working. Neither is Gentoo, for that matter, but, at least
with Gentoo, you'll know how to fix it.


-- 
:wq



Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-08 Thread LinuxIsOne
On Thu, Dec 8, 2011 at 10:56 AM, Michael Mol mike...@gmail.com wrote:

 As long as we're talking about *you*, and not about someone you're
 setting things up for, here's what I'd suggest:

 1) Keep your existing Ubuntu setup operational, at least for a while.
 Gentoo isn't something you should dive into unless you have a
 fallback, at least until you learn enough to be able to fix the things
 you'll encounter.
 2) Set up Gentoo as a second machine; it really is a great way to
 learn how a lot of the moving parts in Linux work.

 Once you've got Gentoo doing everything you want it to do, and you've
 burned yourself a couple times, you'll be in a good position to make a
 decision for yourself. I've actually bounced back and forth between
 Ubuntu and Gentoo twice in the last three or four years, but I think
 I'm finally ready to go steady with Gentoo. :)

 Ubuntu is great for it just works. Ubuntu isn't so great for it
 just keeps working. Neither is Gentoo, for that matter, but, at least
 with Gentoo, you'll know how to fix it.

Ah, thanks for the nice suggestions, I would keep a note of it. I
would install in one old machine, I mean I would try to install Gentoo
after going through the docs..(of course, required in Gentoo). But one
more request can you also suggest about openSUSE? Is openSUSE lies in
the middle between Ubuntu and Gentoo?



Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-08 Thread Lorenzo Bandieri
2011/12/8 LinuxIsOne linuxis...@gmail.com:
 On Thu, Dec 8, 2011 at 9:29 AM, Alan McKinnon alan.mckin...@gmail.com wrote:

 Don't take our word for it, go look for yourself.

 I could give you examples of how that forum works, I could give you
 links that show what we are saying, but NOTHING can prepare you for
 what you really find on the Ubuntu user forums.

 Okay but at least Ubuntu is good for new users and Windows convert and
 for those doesn't it give a learning curve in Linux?


Well, maybe my experience will be useful to you. Ubuntu was my
introduction to linux. First, I'll start by saying that before linux I
didn't know absolutely nothing about computers and the like. I had my
first desktop pc at home (windows xp) when I was 15 or 16 years old.
Before that, only my father owned a pc, for his work, and I was not
allowed to use it. My high school was centered around
humanities/classical studies: ancient greek, latin, philosophy; after
high school, I managed to get into med school. So, no computer
science/informatics at all. However, I was really curios about
computers, and I messed up my family's desktop pc a couple of times :)
At 19, I was given a laptop, only for me (windows vista, if I remember
correctly). I decided to install linux on it, and I chose Ubuntu
because it was the distro of wich I heard about the most. After some
months, I decided to move away from ubuntu because I felt it was too
limited - I wanted to learn. In the following two years I tried other
distros, but at last I felt that only two were apt to me: Gentoo and
Arch Linux. Of these two, I tend to prefer Gentoo.

What's the point in this story: I started as a computer illiterate. I
think that, had I chosen Gentoo (or Arch, or Slackware) as my first
distro, probably I would have given up with linux. I could never get
started so abruptly with the terminal, CLI etc. I needed a gradual
introduction, to get familiar with filesystems, directory hierarchy,
basilar command line usage etc. Ubuntu, at the time, provided this.
Just remember that *probably* you won't learn much by using Ubuntu. If
you want to learn, when you're ready, you will have to move on. You
learn more after an attempt to install Gentoo than in one year of
plain Ubuntu usage :)

At least, that is my real life experience and my opinion. I'm just one
user; on this ML there are really knowledgeable users, so you should
listen to them[1].

[1] BTW, I just want to say that I really love this ML. Thanks guys.

Hope this helps,

Lorenzo

-- 
Nothing is interesting if you're not interested.



Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-08 Thread LinuxIsOne
On Thu, Dec 8, 2011 at 11:19 AM, Lorenzo Bandieri
lorenzo.bandi...@gmail.com wrote:

 Well, maybe my experience will be useful to you. Ubuntu was my
 introduction to linux. First, I'll start by saying that before linux I
 didn't know absolutely nothing about computers and the like. I had my
 first desktop pc at home (windows xp) when I was 15 or 16 years old.
 Before that, only my father owned a pc, for his work, and I was not
 allowed to use it. My high school was centered around
 humanities/classical studies: ancient greek, latin, philosophy; after
 high school, I managed to get into med school. So, no computer
 science/informatics at all. However, I was really curios about
 computers, and I messed up my family's desktop pc a couple of times :)
 At 19, I was given a laptop, only for me (windows vista, if I remember
 correctly). I decided to install linux on it, and I chose Ubuntu
 because it was the distro of wich I heard about the most. After some
 months, I decided to move away from ubuntu because I felt it was too
 limited - I wanted to learn. In the following two years I tried other
 distros, but at last I felt that only two were apt to me: Gentoo and
 Arch Linux. Of these two, I tend to prefer Gentoo.

That's really nice to know.

 What's the point in this story: I started as a computer illiterate. I
 think that, had I chosen Gentoo (or Arch, or Slackware) as my first
 distro, probably I would have given up with linux. I could never get
 started so abruptly with the terminal, CLI etc. I needed a gradual
 introduction, to get familiar with filesystems, directory hierarchy,
 basilar command line usage etc. Ubuntu, at the time, provided this.
 Just remember that *probably* you won't learn much by using Ubuntu. If
 you want to learn, when you're ready, you will have to move on. You
 learn more after an attempt to install Gentoo than in one year of
 plain Ubuntu usage :)

 At least, that is my real life experience and my opinion. I'm just one
 user; on this ML there are really knowledgeable users, so you should
 listen to them[1].

 [1] BTW, I just want to say that I really love this ML. Thanks guys.

Yeahs thanks and your story really gives nice things to remember. I
would definitely try now Gentoo and since it is an advanced version of
Linux usage, so people here are, of course, having more knowledge and
more mature, including you. When you say 'You learn more after an
attempt to install Gentoo than in one year of plain Ubuntu usage :)',
this line is really good to know. If this is true, I guess after some
initial learning I would step towards Gentoo, I bet. But since Gentoo
was not in top 5 at distrowatch.org so that also (earlier) made me
thought that Ubuntu or openSUSE are more matured Linux distributions
but I forgot that the rating I saw was of popularity and not of more
advanced or the one giving more learning curvature.

Thanks.



Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-08 Thread Mick
On Thursday 08 Dec 2011 16:11:56 LinuxIsOne wrote:
 On Thu, Dec 8, 2011 at 10:56 AM, Michael Mol mike...@gmail.com wrote:
  As long as we're talking about *you*, and not about someone you're
  setting things up for, here's what I'd suggest:
  
  1) Keep your existing Ubuntu setup operational, at least for a while.
  Gentoo isn't something you should dive into unless you have a
  fallback, at least until you learn enough to be able to fix the things
  you'll encounter.
  2) Set up Gentoo as a second machine; it really is a great way to
  learn how a lot of the moving parts in Linux work.
  
  Once you've got Gentoo doing everything you want it to do, and you've
  burned yourself a couple times, you'll be in a good position to make a
  decision for yourself. I've actually bounced back and forth between
  Ubuntu and Gentoo twice in the last three or four years, but I think
  I'm finally ready to go steady with Gentoo. :)
  
  Ubuntu is great for it just works. Ubuntu isn't so great for it
  just keeps working. Neither is Gentoo, for that matter, but, at least
  with Gentoo, you'll know how to fix it.
 
 Ah, thanks for the nice suggestions, I would keep a note of it. I
 would install in one old machine, I mean I would try to install Gentoo
 after going through the docs..(of course, required in Gentoo). But one
 more request can you also suggest about openSUSE? Is openSUSE lies in
 the middle between Ubuntu and Gentoo?

OpenSUSE is not that different from Ubuntu, but is a long way from Gentoo.

There is no way to meaningfully compare *Ubuntu and OpenSUSE, because it 
depends what suits your taste and preferences.  You can install both, run them 
for a few weeks and see which you feel more comfortable with.

Last time I installed OpenSUSE (some years ago) I had to reinstall it when 
time came to upgrade to the latest version.  With Ubuntu the upgrade path was 
pretty seamless.  The Ubuntu devs had it all scripted out via the update 
manager.  So, Ubuntu is I think easier to look after and keep upgrading than 
OpenSUSE was back then.  Not sure how things have evolved since then in the 
OpenSUSE world.  CentOS was no better than OpenSUSE in this regard.

So, for a newcomer to Linux I would recommend *Ubuntu.
-- 
Regards,
Mick


signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part.


Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-08 Thread Frank Steinmetzger
On Thu, Dec 08, 2011 at 08:09:34PM +, Mick wrote:

   Ubuntu is great for it just works. Ubuntu isn't so great for it
   just keeps working. Neither is Gentoo, for that matter, but, at least
   with Gentoo, you'll know how to fix it.
  
  Ah, thanks for the nice suggestions, I would keep a note of it. I
  would install in one old machine, I mean I would try to install Gentoo
  after going through the docs..(of course, required in Gentoo). But one
  more request can you also suggest about openSUSE? Is openSUSE lies in
  the middle between Ubuntu and Gentoo?
 
 OpenSUSE is not that different from Ubuntu, but is a long way from Gentoo.
 
 There is no way to meaningfully compare *Ubuntu and OpenSUSE, because it 
 depends what suits your taste and preferences.  You can install both, run 
 them 
 for a few weeks and see which you feel more comfortable with.
 
 Last time I installed OpenSUSE (some years ago) I had to reinstall it when 
 time came to upgrade to the latest version.  With Ubuntu the upgrade path was 
 pretty seamless.  The Ubuntu devs had it all scripted out via the update 
 manager.  So, Ubuntu is I think easier to look after and keep upgrading than 
 OpenSUSE was back then.  Not sure how things have evolved since then in the 
 OpenSUSE world.  CentOS was no better than OpenSUSE in this regard.
 
 So, for a newcomer to Linux I would recommend *Ubuntu.

I did this in the past. But recently I’m reassessing this, with Ubuntu changing
the default look and the way it works with every other release (remember the
hassle about window buttons to the left by default?). I can’t really explain
-- let alone justify -- to a newbie, who had to adapt from Win to Ubuntu that
he has to do so again, whether he wants to or not. Plus it seems to me they
are trying to become Apple in the Linux world, with own services (and design).
I am totally at a loss with entry-level distros right now. 

I tried Mint, also the new one with Gnome 3. The praised Mint menu seems
overloaded to me (it shows too much at once IMHO). I somehow dislike custom
layers over a standard interface, much like, if I bought an HTC Android, I
would reflash it without Sense UI, but I’m digressing.

OpenSuse seems even more overloaded. Albeit it provides a whole environment,
Yast was full of stuff a simple user will never need. It also caused a very
long and voluminous installation process.
I must add though that I peeked into both Mint and Suse only for a day or so,
without ever using it myself, so I don’t know jack about update procedures.

A friend of mine wanted Linux, so I installed Debian stable for her with KDE
4.4. It’s not bleeding edge, but it works because it doesn’t change much (hence
keeps working) and because she doesn’t do a lot of fancy stuff. (And also
because I used Debian testing for a while, so I know a bit about how to do some
helpdesking).
-- 
Gruß | Greetings | Qapla'
I forbid any use of my email addresses with Facebook services.

Everything is poisonous -- it just comes down to the dosage.


pgpxGzE4PrJFs.pgp
Description: PGP signature


Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-07 Thread Stroller

On 6 December 2011, at 23:25, Grant Edwards wrote:
 ...
 The Ubuntu documentation seems to be mainly user-forum threads full of
 wrong answers posted by people who didn't understand the question.

I tried Ubuntu, hated this *so* much.

I'm sure all the respondents were just trying to be helpful, but they made 
Ubuntu look like the distro of idiots.

Stroller.




Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-07 Thread LinuxIsOne
On Wed, Dec 7, 2011 at 5:20 AM, Stroller strol...@stellar.eclipse.co.uk wrote:

 I tried Ubuntu, hated this *so* much.

 I'm sure all the respondents were just trying to be helpful, but they made 
 Ubuntu look like the distro of idiots.

How do you say like this? Can you give me an example please?



Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-03 Thread Stroller

On 2 December 2011, at 17:48, LinuxIsOne wrote:
 ...
 Why I asked to just know if Gentoo is better or openSUSE is better for
 a novice who want to learn Linux, just coming directly from
 Windows...that's why...However, I have liked the Ubuntu (since it is
 easy and nice) but don't know about all Linux in generalis Gentoo
 is also using the same Linux which Ubuntu is using?

IMO you need to try it for yourself. If you have an old PC or a spare 
hard-drive then it doesn't cost you anything to install a distro and try it for 
a few days.

IMO the most important thing about a distro is not it's technical pros and 
cons, but simply how it suits you - how you get along with it.

Having said that, you mention Ubuntu in your comment above. If you haven't used 
Ubuntu yet, then I suggest it for a few months first. If you have, can you tell 
us why you're thinking of changing?

Stroller.




Re: Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-03 Thread Volker Armin Hemmann
Why I asked to just know if Gentoo is better or openSUSE is better for
a novice who want to learn Linux, just coming directly from
Windows...that's why...However, I have liked the Ubuntu (since it is
easy and nice) but don't know about all Linux in generalis Gentoo
is also using the same Linux which Ubuntu is using?


since you don't even know what linux is - go opensuse. It is much, much easier 
to install and setup.

Gentoo is only for you if you like tuning, configuring and if you want the 
system be as close as your personal ideal as possible. Which means:

reading and learning a lot
making a lot of mistakes
redoing
be prepared to pull out shell based text tools and fix the mess you created,

Go opensuse. it is much more usable for a novice.

And to answer your question:

no, gentoo is not using the same linux as ubuntu
nor does opensuse.

All distributions use some linux version and add their own patches.

With the exception of gentoo where you can easily use a completely unpatched 
linux kernel.

-- 
#163933

Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-02 Thread Andrew Tchernoivanov
Hi!

I use gentoo on my desktop (P4, 2 Gb RAM) and openSuSe on laptop (Lenovo
x200s). They both work perfectly well, especially when you precisely know
what you are expecting from OS )) Regarding your questions:

About DE:
 I've tried to use Enlightenment with SuSe, and worked very well (only
little changes with networking).

Applications:
 I have texlive, pdftk, sipp and ns-2 working perfectly on both systems.
General applications like LibreOffice,
Gimp, browser works fine too.

The only thin is really annoying in openSuSe is /usr/lib/tracker-* which
loads CPU by 90% while searching
for media files, etc.. I recommend to disable it - I haven't found anything
useful by using this application.

Hope this helps you.

P.S. Sorry it there were some mistakes - English isn't my native language.


On Fri, Dec 2, 2011 at 6:41 PM, LinuxIsOne linuxis...@gmail.com wrote:

 Hello,

 Does one have the experience for the following:

 gentoo vs openSUSE

 for ease of use, better navigation, applications working perfectly
 without any crash(es), better up gradations, smooth working,
 etc..etc...

 Best Regards.




-- 
С уважением,
Черноиванов Андрей


Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-02 Thread LinuxIsOne
2011/12/2 Andrew Tchernoivanov:

 Hi!

Hello.

 I use gentoo on my desktop (P4, 2 Gb RAM) and openSuSe on laptop (Lenovo
 x200s). They both work perfectly well, especially when you precisely know
 what you are expecting from OS )) Regarding your questions:

Ok well.

 About DE:
  I've tried to use Enlightenment with SuSe, and worked very well (only
 little changes with networking).

 Applications:
  I have texlive, pdftk, sipp and ns-2 working perfectly on both systems.
 General applications like LibreOffice,
 Gimp, browser works fine too.

 The only thin is really annoying in openSuSe is /usr/lib/tracker-* which
 loads CPU by 90% while searching
 for media files, etc.. I recommend to disable it - I haven't found anything
 useful by using this application.

Okay.

 Hope this helps you.

Yeah.

 P.S. Sorry it there were some mistakes - English isn't my native language.

Not a problem, that is also not a native language for me!

Why I asked to just know if Gentoo is better or openSUSE is better for
a novice who want to learn Linux, just coming directly from
Windows...that's why...However, I have liked the Ubuntu (since it is
easy and nice) but don't know about all Linux in generalis Gentoo
is also using the same Linux which Ubuntu is using?

Cheers.



Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-02 Thread Mick
On Friday 02 Dec 2011 14:41:29 LinuxIsOne wrote:
 Hello,
 
 Does one have the experience for the following:
 
 gentoo vs openSUSE
 
 for ease of use, better navigation, applications working perfectly
 without any crash(es), better up gradations, smooth working,
 etc..etc...
 
 Best Regards.

If you want *exactly* what OpenSUSE have included in their distro then 
OpenSUSE is for you.  Some applications and the whole system will run slower 
than Gentoo.  Invariably some applications could experience crashes and what 
not - any distro would from time to time have such problems and may not be 
distro specific anyway, but application specific.

If you want to include additional applications or versions of applications 
that OpenSUSE repos do not cater for, then you may run into dependency hell.  
At best, some apps will just not install or work as intended.  At worst you 
could break the underlying distro if you try hard enough and have to 
reinstall.

With Gentoo you have higher flexibility on what you install and portage is 
definitely thousands times better than YaST, in terms of configurabilty.  You 
will still get the odd application that is buggy, but as a rule your system 
will run lighter and faster because each binary is compiled from source with 
the CFALGS and USE flags that you have specified for your system.  On the other 
hand it will take some time and effort to keep your Gentoo up to date.

Another difference between OpenSUSE and Gentoo is that you will not need to 
reinstall Gentoo to get the latest desktop, or init system or what-ever system 
wide upgrade is next.  With OpenSUSE upgrades imply a reinstallation (unless 
YaST got cleverer since the last time I used it).  Invariably you will also 
never need to reinstall Gentoo to fix any breakages - most problems you may 
come across you will learn how to recover from with clever use of portage.

In conclusion:

If you prefer quick installation and easy/quick updates, but with limited 
choice on what gets installed and how it is configured, and the OpenSUSE suite 
of packages will meet your application needs comprehensively, then OpenSUSE is 
a well polished distro that will fit the bill.

If you value higher performance and a much higher degree of configurability, 
then Gentoo will be your choice;  but that comes at the expense of a 
protracted installation process (especially if you have not done this before) 
and some admin time on a regular basis to keep your system and applications up 
to date.

With Gentoo you will be *forced* to learn a lot to install your system and 
keep it running.  With OpenSUSE the learning curve will likely be considerably 
flatter.

It would be advisable to try them both out in LiveCDs (or even install them in 
VMs) to see which you feel more comfortable working with.  For a Gentoo based 
LiveCD you could try Sabayon:  http://www.sabayon.org/ and this may also be 
used for a quick (binary) installation of a Gentoo-like system.

HTH.
-- 
Regards,
Mick


signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part.


Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-02 Thread Dale

LinuxIsOne wrote:
Why I asked to just know if Gentoo is better or openSUSE is better for 
a novice who want to learn Linux, just coming directly from 
Windows...that's why...However, I have liked the Ubuntu (since it is 
easy and nice) but don't know about all Linux in generalis Gentoo 
is also using the same Linux which Ubuntu is using? Cheers. 


Better depends on what you expect.  If you want to learn about Linux, 
Gentoo will teach you a lot.  Heck, you will learn a lot by the time you 
get it installed and get to your first boot prompt.  I get the 
impression that you don't realize how in depth Gentoo is.  Gentoo can be 
installed by a Linux newcomer but it will not be a walk in the park.  I 
used Mandrake for 6 months or so and it took me about 3 tries to get to 
a point where Gentoo would boot up.  It took a while more to get 
everything working still.  I had to redo my kernel several times.


The point I am making is, it is not how different Gentoo is from other 
distros, it's whether it is something you need and want to put the time 
in to learn.  Gentoo doesn't have a GUI installer and you do have to 
compile everything you install.  I recently installed Kubuntu for my 
Brother.  It is a walk in the park compared to installing Gentoo.  Did I 
learn anything about Linux, not hardly.  I don't think Kubuntu is made 
to teach a lot about Linux.  It's just made to install easily and 
quickly without much fuss.


I do hope you will try Gentoo tho.  It is sort of addicting at times.  lol

Dale

:-)  :-)

--
I am only responsible for what I said ... Not for what you understood or how 
you interpreted my words!




Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-02 Thread Pandu Poluan
On Dec 3, 2011 3:06 AM, Dale rdalek1...@gmail.com wrote:

 LinuxIsOne wrote:

 Why I asked to just know if Gentoo is better or openSUSE is better for a
novice who want to learn Linux, just coming directly from Windows...that's
why...However, I have liked the Ubuntu (since it is easy and nice) but
don't know about all Linux in generalis Gentoo is also using the same
Linux which Ubuntu is using? Cheers.


 Better depends on what you expect.  If you want to learn about Linux,
Gentoo will teach you a lot.  Heck, you will learn a lot by the time you
get it installed and get to your first boot prompt.  I get the impression
that you don't realize how in depth Gentoo is.  Gentoo can be installed by
a Linux newcomer but it will not be a walk in the park.  I used Mandrake
for 6 months or so and it took me about 3 tries to get to a point where
Gentoo would boot up.  It took a while more to get everything working
still.  I had to redo my kernel several times.

 The point I am making is, it is not how different Gentoo is from other
distros, it's whether it is something you need and want to put the time in
to learn.  Gentoo doesn't have a GUI installer and you do have to compile
everything you install.  I recently installed Kubuntu for my Brother.  It
is a walk in the park compared to installing Gentoo.  Did I learn anything
about Linux, not hardly.  I don't think Kubuntu is made to teach a lot
about Linux.  It's just made to install easily and quickly without much
fuss.

 I do hope you will try Gentoo tho.  It is sort of addicting at times.  lol


Indeed! Especially control freaks like me :-)

But seriously, I personally found Gentoo to be the most logical Linux
distro. Yes, the initial barrier (installation) is daunting, so to speak,
but after doing it successfully, one can immediately intuit what's going
on. Installing and configuring other packages becomes piece of  cake.

The logical way of Gentoo even extends to its packages. For instance,
packages that are meant to be run as services/daemons will *certainly* have
a pair of files in conf.d and init.d. Customizable environs are in env.d
and profile.d. And so on.

I've used Linux exclusively as servers, and I have dabbled with Red Hat,
CentOS, Ubuntu, Debian, and Arch, but Gentoo wins hands down for its
logicality.

Not to mention that I can customize my servers exactly to my
specifications, instead of having to put up with cruft that the distro
maintainer feel as a must have. Case in point : how many distros allow
you to choose which cron daemon you want to use?

Another plus point is the almost complete devel tools provided out of the
box: the gcc suite. Now if I happen across an open source project that
hasn't made it yet to the portage tree, I can just download and compile it
myself.

Related to that, is the great job Portage did regarding dependency hell.
Since I am no longer hostage to the whims of the distro maintainer re:
versions of libraries installed, if a program needs a library that's newer
than the current 'stable' version, I can just keyword the needed version
and compile away.

Rgds,


Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-02 Thread Frank Steinmetzger
On Sat, Dec 03, 2011 at 07:53:58AM +0700, Pandu Poluan wrote:
 On Dec 3, 2011 3:06 AM, Dale rdalek1...@gmail.com wrote:
 
  LinuxIsOne wrote:
 
  Why I asked to just know if Gentoo is better or openSUSE is better for a
 novice who want to learn Linux, just coming directly from Windows...that's
 why...However, I have liked the Ubuntu (since it is easy and nice) but
 don't know about all Linux in generalis Gentoo is also using the same
 Linux which Ubuntu is using? Cheers.

A small off-topic hint, Pandu: your mailer is breaking the quoting, because it
only sets a quote marker to the first line of a paragraph, omitting the
following lines (See my quote of your message above). Can you please look into
your settings to correct it? Thanks.
-- 
Gruß | Greetings | Qapla'
I forbid any use of my email addresses with Facebook services.

Experience -- specialist term for tried mistakes of older employees.


pgp0yJoajaPPK.pgp
Description: PGP signature


Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-02 Thread Michael Mol
On Fri, Dec 2, 2011 at 7:53 PM, Pandu Poluan pa...@poluan.info wrote:
 Another plus point is the almost complete devel tools provided out of the
 box: the gcc suite. Now if I happen across an open source project that
 hasn't made it yet to the portage tree, I can just download and compile it
 myself.

This. Very much this. My dive into Gentoo came as I was fed up with
Debian and Ubuntu having buggy and/or outdated versions of multimedia
encoding packages while trying to configure a box specced for live
transcoding of h.264 to something my PS3 would like.

-- 
:wq



Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-02 Thread Pandu Poluan
On Dec 3, 2011 8:25 AM, Frank Steinmetzger war...@gmx.de wrote:

 On Sat, Dec 03, 2011 at 07:53:58AM +0700, Pandu Poluan wrote:
  On Dec 3, 2011 3:06 AM, Dale rdalek1...@gmail.com wrote:
  
   LinuxIsOne wrote:
  
   Why I asked to just know if Gentoo is better or openSUSE is better
for a
  novice who want to learn Linux, just coming directly from
Windows...that's
  why...However, I have liked the Ubuntu (since it is easy and nice) but
  don't know about all Linux in generalis Gentoo is also using the
same
  Linux which Ubuntu is using? Cheers.

 A small off-topic hint, Pandu: your mailer is breaking the quoting,
because it
 only sets a quote marker to the first line of a paragraph, omitting the
 following lines (See my quote of your message above). Can you please look
into
 your settings to correct it? Thanks.

*sighs*

Blame it on Google...

I'm typing on Android's Gmail client.

Rgds,


Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-02 Thread Pandu Poluan
On Dec 3, 2011 9:14 AM, Michael Mol mike...@gmail.com wrote:

 On Fri, Dec 2, 2011 at 7:53 PM, Pandu Poluan pa...@poluan.info wrote:
  Another plus point is the almost complete devel tools provided out of
the
  box: the gcc suite. Now if I happen across an open source project that
  hasn't made it yet to the portage tree, I can just download and compile
it
  myself.

 This. Very much this. My dive into Gentoo came as I was fed up with
 Debian and Ubuntu having buggy and/or outdated versions of multimedia
 encoding packages while trying to configure a box specced for live
 transcoding of h.264 to something my PS3 would like.


Ha, same with me :-)

But in my case, it's esoteric stuffs like: latest iptables, xtables-addons
(and its ipset modules), fetchmail, postgreSQL, ... and an initramfs-less
system :-)

Rgds,


Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-02 Thread Dale

Pandu Poluan wrote:



Indeed! Especially control freaks like me :-)

But seriously, I personally found Gentoo to be the most logical Linux 
distro. Yes, the initial barrier (installation) is daunting, so to 
speak, but after doing it successfully, one can immediately intuit 
what's going on. Installing and configuring other packages becomes 
piece of  cake.


The logical way of Gentoo even extends to its packages. For instance, 
packages that are meant to be run as services/daemons will *certainly* 
have a pair of files in conf.d and init.d. Customizable environs are 
in env.d and profile.d. And so on.


I've used Linux exclusively as servers, and I have dabbled with Red 
Hat, CentOS, Ubuntu, Debian, and Arch, but Gentoo wins hands down for 
its logicality.


Not to mention that I can customize my servers exactly to my 
specifications, instead of having to put up with cruft that the distro 
maintainer feel as a must have. Case in point : how many distros 
allow you to choose which cron daemon you want to use?


Another plus point is the almost complete devel tools provided out of 
the box: the gcc suite. Now if I happen across an open source project 
that hasn't made it yet to the portage tree, I can just download and 
compile it myself.


Related to that, is the great job Portage did regarding dependency 
hell. Since I am no longer hostage to the whims of the distro 
maintainer re: versions of libraries installed, if a program needs a 
library that's newer than the current 'stable' version, I can just 
keyword the needed version and compile away.


Rgds,




This is true but the OP may not really need this type of control.  Most 
people, newcomers especially, just want something that is easy and sort 
of learn a bit and see if Linux is for them.  Some people just aren't 
wanting to be geeky at all.  They want a OS that will take care of 
everything for them.  In that case, Gentoo is not going to be worth the 
effort.


Me, I have a Desktop with no real special needs.  I just wanted to be 
able to learn about Linux, not have some bunch of junk that I never ever 
intend to use installed and be able to update without standing on my 
head with my small toe up one nostril trying to jump hoops.  Mandrake 
had a horrible update process and I got tired of it quick.  If you could 
insert CD, install and not need to update anything, then you were good 
to go.  If you install and then need to update something, ps.  Flip 
upside down and assume the position.


Gentoo does have a lot of good points, especially for me.  It is just 
not going to be easy and hand holding at first for a newcomer.  The OP 
will learn a lot and as I pointed out, it can be addicting.  Just turn 
off the quiet output setting and see what Linux is really all about.  ;-)


Dale

:-)  :-)

--
I am only responsible for what I said ... Not for what you understood or how 
you interpreted my words!




Re: [gentoo-user] can one tell me: gentoo vs opensuse

2011-12-02 Thread Frank Steinmetzger
On Fri, Dec 02, 2011 at 09:09:38PM -0500, Michael Mol wrote:
 On Fri, Dec 2, 2011 at 7:53 PM, Pandu Poluan pa...@poluan.info wrote:
  Another plus point is the almost complete devel tools provided out of the
  box: the gcc suite. Now if I happen across an open source project that
  hasn't made it yet to the portage tree, I can just download and compile it
  myself.
 
 This. Very much this. My dive into Gentoo came as I was fed up with
 Debian and Ubuntu having buggy and/or outdated versions of multimedia
 encoding packages while trying to configure a box specced for live
 transcoding of h.264 to something my PS3 would like.

Though Gentoo was my first distro to begin with, the devel stuff in
Debian/Ubuntu is also a big nuisance for me, because you have to “spam” the
equivalent of your world file with numerous dev packages or libs if you want to
install some application from source (like I once tried with Amarok in Debian
Squeeze).
On the other hand one could of course argue that Gentoo is wasting a lot of
space because it is always installing all dev files, like /usr/include,
/lib/**/*.a and stuff. But that’s something else. :)
-- 
Gruß | Greetings | Qapla'
I forbid any use of my email addresses with Facebook services.

Bosses are like timpani: the more hollow they are, the louder they sound.


pgpT818AjtESZ.pgp
Description: PGP signature