Re: [ccp4bb] Copy NCS chain in coot

2011-03-31 Thread Javier Garcia
Dear Zhang yu, I also found that same problem recently. I think is a small bug from Coot. It will only copy NCS if the molecule's name you want to copy is molecule A. So maybe will work if you rename your built chain as A. Good luck! Javier On 31/03/11 00:16, zhang yu wrote: Dear all, I

Re: [ccp4bb] [phenixbb] what to do with disordered side chains

2011-03-31 Thread Huanwang Yang
If a part of sequence has no density, this part will be cut from coordinates. If the side chain of a residue is lack of density, the opinion is not converged. What about the ligand, if no density is observed? Huanwang Ed Pozharski wrote: The results of the online survey on what to do with

Re: [ccp4bb] titering baculovirus ?

2011-03-31 Thread Bertrand, Jay Aaron [Nervianoms]
I checked with someone in our protein production group and got the following response: We also stopped doing the virus titration with the plaque assay and instead are performing expression test with different concentration of virus from the 3rd amplification. But for some viruses we still have

Re: [ccp4bb] [phenixbb] what to do with disordered side chains

2011-03-31 Thread Randy Read
Judging from some examples in the literature, if there's no density for the ligand, you publish in Nature! On 31 Mar 2011, at 14:32, Huanwang Yang wrote: If a part of sequence has no density, this part will be cut from coordinates. If the side chain of a residue is lack of density, the

[ccp4bb] Question about TEV cleavage

2011-03-31 Thread Prince, D Bryan
Hello all: I am curious about what level of recovery is reasonable when performing a TEV cleavage to remove 6HIS tags (N-terminal) from a protein. Currently we are experiencing 50% loss of soluble protein after TEV cleavage, and feel that this is too much. Are there better systems for his tag

[ccp4bb] off topic: protease identification

2011-03-31 Thread Brett, Thomas
Hi all: I was wondering if anyone had any tips on identifying proteases. I have a protein for which I know the proteolytic cleavage site. What are the best ways to identify the protease that does the cutting either: 1) bioinformatically (i.e., a good database to search using the cleavage site

Re: [ccp4bb] what to do with disordered side chains

2011-03-31 Thread Herman . Schreuder
Dear Quyen, I am afraid you won't get any better answers than you got so far. There is no holy bible telling you what to do with disordered side chains. I fully agree with James that you should try to get the best possible model, which best explains your data and that will be your decision.

Re: [ccp4bb] Question about TEV cleavage

2011-03-31 Thread Xiaopeng Hu
Our experience is do not shake the tube during TEV cleavage,I dont know why, but it does help. xiaopeng

Re: [ccp4bb] titering baculovirus ?

2011-03-31 Thread Brad Bennett
Though I'm not meaning to turn this into a plaque assay burn session, for many reasons we have also abandoned it and instead titer our baculovirus stocks (P3 and P4) using flow cytometry. We use an antibody against viral gp64 that has been labeled with PE and stain infected cells in 96 well plates

[ccp4bb] problem of conventions

2011-03-31 Thread Anita Lewit-Bentley
Dear all, I would like to share my experiencde with a rather unexpected problem of indexing conventions. Perhaps I can save people some time I have a crystal in the more unusual P21212 space-group (No 18). Its unit cell lengths are bac (please note). I systematically use XDS for data

Re: [ccp4bb] problem of conventions

2011-03-31 Thread Santarsiero, Bernard D.
If you are using CCP4, it can accomodate P22121. However, just reindex in CCP4 to the correct setting with P21212. Bernie Santarsiero On Thu, March 31, 2011 9:28 am, Anita Lewit-Bentley wrote: Dear all, I would like to share my experiencde with a rather unexpected problem of indexing

Re: [ccp4bb] Copy NCS chain in coot

2011-03-31 Thread zhang yu
Dear Javier, Thanks for your reply. I am using coot 0.6.1, and I could copy molecules with names besides A only if chains are already present in both NCS. For chains which are only present in one NCS , I did find out a way to copy to the other NCS by using 'Find NCS ligand' , although it is not

Re: [ccp4bb] Question about TEV cleavage

2011-03-31 Thread Charles Allerston
I echo this. Some time ago I was working on a target which seemed to precipitate when cleaving overnight with TEV. I wasted a fair bit of time trying to optimise cleavage conditions with a myriad of buffers. In the end, just by not agitating my solution, there was no precipitation and

Re: [ccp4bb] what to do with disordered side chains

2011-03-31 Thread Jacob Keller
Why not have the b-factors take care of it until some magic cutoff number? When they reach the cutoff, two things happen: 1. Occupancies are set to zero for those side chains, to represent our lack of ability to model the region, 2. B-factors are set to exactly 500, as a flag allowing casual

Re: [ccp4bb] problem of conventions

2011-03-31 Thread Phil Evans
The IUCr standard is to make abc, see http://nvl.nist.gov/pub/nistpubs/jres/107/4/j74mig.pdf http://nvl.nist.gov/pub/nistpubs/jres/106/6/j66mig.pdf and P 2 21 21 is a perfectly valid space group Pointless will reindex within the same point group, or you can choose the abc convention (SETTING

Re: [ccp4bb] what to do with disordered side chains

2011-03-31 Thread Nat Echols
On Thu, Mar 31, 2011 at 7:42 AM, Jacob Keller j-kell...@fsm.northwestern.edu wrote: Why not have the b-factors take care of it until some magic cutoff number? When they reach the cutoff, two things happen: 1. Occupancies are set to zero for those side chains, to represent our lack of

Re: [ccp4bb] what to do with disordered side chains

2011-03-31 Thread Phoebe Rice
- they all know what B is and how to look for regions of high B (with, say, pymol) and they know not to make firm conclusions about H-bonds to flaming red side chains. But this knowledge may be quite wrong. If the flaming red really indicates large vibrational motion then yes, one whould

Re: [ccp4bb] what to do with disordered side chains

2011-03-31 Thread Jacob Keller
Well, I guess I was thinking to make the b-factor such a preposterous value that no one would possibly believe it. Setting occupancies to zero effectively places a stumbling block, because people see the residues and think they are actually supported by data. So to counter-balance this, I thought

Re: [ccp4bb] what to do with disordered side chains

2011-03-31 Thread Herman . Schreuder
Dear Jacob, What do we gain? As Dale pointed out, we are already abusing either occupancy, B-factor or delete the side chain to compensate for our inability to tell the user that the side chain is disordered. With your proposal, we would fudge both occupancy and B-factor, which in my eyes is

Re: [ccp4bb] Question about TEV cleavage

2011-03-31 Thread Laurie Betts
We have the same experience with the DO NOT AGITATE. We purify our own His-tagged TEV protease, and flash-freeze it IMMEDIATELY after IMAC prep at about 1 mg/mL. Laurie Betts UNC On Thu, Mar 31, 2011 at 10:37 AM, Charles Allerston charles.allers...@sgc.ox.ac.uk wrote: I echo this. Some

Re: [ccp4bb] off topic: protease identification

2011-03-31 Thread S. Jack Lin
Hi Tom, You can try the MEROPS database. There is a search feature called What peptidases can cleave this bond. http://merops.sanger.ac.uk/cgi-bin/specsearch.pl Cheers, Jack On Thu, Mar 31, 2011 at 6:59 AM, Brett, Thomas tbr...@dom.wustl.edu wrote: Hi all: I was wondering if anyone had any

Re: [ccp4bb] Question about TEV cleavage

2011-03-31 Thread Klaus Piontek
And not at full moon! Klaus Am 31.03.2011 um 16:23 schrieb Xiaopeng Hu: Our experience is do not shake the tube during TEV cleavage,I dont know why, but it does help. xiaopeng Dr. Klaus Piontek Albert-Ludwigs-University Freiburg Institute of Organic Chemistry and Biochemistry, Room 401

Re: [ccp4bb] what to do with disordered side chains

2011-03-31 Thread Quyen Hoang
Thank you for your post, Herman. Since there is no holy bible to provide guidance, perhaps we should hold off the idea of electing a powerful dictator to enforce this? - at least until we all can come to a consensus on how the dictator should dictate... Cheers, Quyen On Mar 31, 2011, at

Re: [ccp4bb] what to do with disordered side chains

2011-03-31 Thread Ed Pozharski
On Thu, 2011-03-31 at 17:04 +0200, herman.schreu...@sanofi-aventis.com wrote: Maybe we should really start using cif files, which allow to specify coordinate uncertainties. PDB has SIGATM record for that purpose -- I'd jump in myself, if I weren't so good at whistling.

Re: [ccp4bb] what to do with disordered side chains

2011-03-31 Thread Peter Keller
On Thu, 2011-03-31 at 11:27 -0400, Quyen Hoang wrote: Thank you for your post, Herman. Since there is no holy bible to provide guidance, perhaps we should hold off the idea of electing a powerful dictator to enforce this? - at least until we all can come to a consensus on how the dictator

[ccp4bb] The meaning of B-factor, was Re: [ccp4bb] what to do with disordered side chains

2011-03-31 Thread Zbyszek Otwinowski
The B-factor in crystallography represents the convolution (sum) of two types of uncertainties about the atom (electron cloud) position: 1) dispersion of atom positions in crystal lattice 2) uncertainty of the experimenter's knowledge about the atom position. In general, uncertainty needs not

Re: [ccp4bb] what to do with disordered side chains

2011-03-31 Thread Roberts, Sue A - (suer)
Regarding suggestions that the pdb or the IUCR to tell us what to do: IMO - Neither of the usual solutions - (a) deleting side chains when there is no density or (b) letting B factors go where they will - is without problems (this is clear from the ongoing discussion). I would be really

Re: [ccp4bb] what to do with disordered side chains

2011-03-31 Thread Gerard Bricogne
Dear Quyen, On Thu, Mar 31, 2011 at 11:27:58AM -0400, Quyen Hoang wrote: Thank you for your post, Herman. Since there is no holy bible to provide guidance, perhaps we should hold off the idea of electing a powerful dictator to enforce this? - at least until we all can come to a consensus on

Re: [ccp4bb] titering baculovirus ?

2011-03-31 Thread Katya Heldwein
A related question: how do most people amplify their baculovirus stocks? Adherent cultures vs suspension? Fold dilution at each stage (P1 to P2, P2 to P3)? Duration of each amplification stage? We have some viral stocks that go off rather quickly (1-2 months) despite being stored with FBS in a

Re: [ccp4bb] The meaning of B-factor, was Re: [ccp4bb] what to do with disordered side chains

2011-03-31 Thread Frank von Delft
This is a lovely summary, and we should make our students read it. - But I'm afraid I do not see how it supports the closing statement in the last paragraph... phx. On 31/03/2011 17:06, Zbyszek Otwinowski wrote: The B-factor in crystallography represents the convolution (sum) of two types of

Re: [ccp4bb] The meaning of B-factor, was Re: [ccp4bb] what to do with disordered side chains

2011-03-31 Thread Hailiang Zhang
Dear Zbyszek: Thanks a lot for your good summary. It is very interesting but, do you think there are some references for more detailed description, especially from mathematics point of view about correlating B-factor to the Gaussian probability distribution (the B-factor unit of A^2 is my first

Re: [ccp4bb] titering baculovirus ?

2011-03-31 Thread Nathaniel Clark
We do adherent if we have a small volume of low titer virus, but as soon as we have a decent titer we will start with a 30 ml suspension flask. Normally I add something like 0.5 ml, which is probably more then I need. We only use serum free media right now. As I mentioned, if you need to boost

Re: [ccp4bb] step refine speed of wincoot - a little drawback of the new interruptible_fit_protein() function in wincoot

2011-03-31 Thread Bernhard C. Lohkamp
Thank you for the comment. You are correct that there are being backups made in the newer interruptable fit function (they were't previously in the uninterruptable fitting). I wasnt thinking about that (*). This may (especially on windows) slow down things a great deal as we write and gzip these

Re: [ccp4bb] what to do with disordered side chains

2011-03-31 Thread Jacob Keller
What do we gain? As Dale pointed out, we are already abusing either occupancy, B-factor or delete the side chain to compensate for our inability to tell the user that the side chain is disordered. With your proposal, we would fudge both occupancy and B-factor, which in my eyes is even worse

Re: [ccp4bb] problem of conventions

2011-03-31 Thread Tim Gruene
Dear Anita, I happen to have a very similar problem today. Does XDS use the desired setting if you provide it with the correct cell and space group during the IDXREF step? You can otherwise re-index in CORRECT. To comment on Phil: I fed the mtz-file from pointless into ctruncate (or maybe it

Re: [ccp4bb] titering baculovirus ?

2011-03-31 Thread Nathaniel Clark
We don't do anything special to store the virus, just a dark fridge. You do need to mix well as the virus can settle. You might want to try this 'TIPS' approach. Basically you freeze baculovirus infected cells, and use them as your virus innoculum. I think I tried it once and it didn't really

Re: [ccp4bb] titering baculovirus ?

2011-03-31 Thread chitra shintre
Hi, We have observed this virus going off within 2 months as well. ...any idea why this happens? Chitra On 31 March 2011 18:07, Nathaniel Clark nathanielcl...@gmail.com wrote: We do adherent if we have a small volume of low titer virus, but as soon as we have a decent titer we will start with

Re: [ccp4bb] what to do with disordered side chains

2011-03-31 Thread Nat Echols
On Thu, Mar 31, 2011 at 10:14 AM, Jacob Keller j-kell...@fsm.northwestern.edu wrote: Also, setting occupancy = zero is not fudging but rather respectfully declining to comment based on lack of data. I think it is exactly the same as omitting residues one cannot see in the density. No,

Re: [ccp4bb] The meaning of B-factor, was Re: [ccp4bb] what to do with disordered side chains

2011-03-31 Thread Ethan Merritt
On Thursday, March 31, 2011 10:05:22 am Hailiang Zhang wrote: Dear Zbyszek: Thanks a lot for your good summary. It is very interesting but, do you think there are some references for more detailed description, especially from mathematics point of view about correlating B-factor to the

Re: [ccp4bb] problem of conventions

2011-03-31 Thread Ian Tickle
To comment on Phil: I fed the mtz-file from pointless into ctruncate (or maybe it was scala) which left the space group string (P2 21 21) but turned the space group number 18 into 3018 - this does screw up autosharp and maybe also other programs which use the space group number/ symbol

Re: [ccp4bb] The meaning of B-factor, was Re: [ccp4bb] what to do with disordered side chains

2011-03-31 Thread Dale Tronrud
While what you say here is quite true and is useful for us to remember, your list is quite short. I can add another 3) The systematic error introduced by assuming full occupancy for all sites. There are, of course, many other factors that we don't account for that our refinement programs

Re: [ccp4bb] problem of conventions

2011-03-31 Thread Ian Tickle
I would like to share my experiencde with a rather unexpected problem of indexing conventions. Perhaps I can save people some time I have a crystal in the more unusual P21212 space-group (No 18). Its unit cell lengths are bac (please note). I systematically use XDS for data

Re: [ccp4bb] what to do with disordered side chains

2011-03-31 Thread Dale Tronrud
On 3/31/2011 10:14 AM, Jacob Keller wrote: What do we gain? As Dale pointed out, we are already abusing either occupancy, B-factor or delete the side chain to compensate for our inability to tell the user that the side chain is disordered. With your proposal, we would fudge both occupancy and

Re: [ccp4bb] problem of conventions

2011-03-31 Thread Santarsiero, Bernard D.
Interesting. My IT, both volume I and volume A (1983) only have P21212 for space group #18. Do I have to purchase a new volume A every year to keep up with the new conventions? Cheers, Bernie On Thu, March 31, 2011 12:57 pm, Ian Tickle wrote: I would like to share my experiencde with a rather

[ccp4bb] Question about GST cleavage

2011-03-31 Thread gauri misra
Just an offshoot of the same Question.. I would like to ask whether the same applies for GST-tag digestion using thrombin.. No agitation gives better results in the above case too... Any personal experiences On Thu, Mar 31, 2011 at 11:29 AM, Klaus Piontek klaus.pion...@ocbc.uni-freiburg.de

Re: [ccp4bb] titering baculovirus ?

2011-03-31 Thread Chun Luo
As many have mentioned, there is no need to titer baculoviruses for protein expression purpose. Plaque assay or other titering methods can give 10-fold variation between two operators. Cells can be different from time to time as well. Sf9 cells in different labs are quite different. MOI

Re: [ccp4bb] Question about TEV cleavage

2011-03-31 Thread Chun Luo
Properly made TEV protease should work with or without rocking. We have done QC of our TurboTEV, a dual GST- and His-tagged TEV, under many conditions and used on hundreds of proteins. The most common cause of incomplete digestion is the insolubility of target protein or bad construct design.

Re: [ccp4bb] titering baculovirus ?

2011-03-31 Thread Nathaniel Clark
On another note, we have moved from baculovirus to stable poly or monoclonal Tn5 cell lines using the pIB/V5-HIS vector. It removes all concerns about titering and viral propagation, and for most of our proteins, the expression level is the same or better. We secrete all our proteins, so the

Re: [ccp4bb] problem of conventions

2011-03-31 Thread Ian Tickle
There are no 'new' conventions to keep up with: recent editions of the old volume 1 or new A do not disagree on the question of the unit cell conventions (except for minor details which don't affect the majority of the common space groups), where by recent I mean going back ~ 70 years. So it's

Re: [ccp4bb] Question about TEV cleavage

2011-03-31 Thread Zhijie Li
Totally agree with Chun. We are using a His tagged S219V construct that's very similary to the one described in the Waugh paper. To my experience, agitation, 37C incubation, low salt buffer, (etc.?), should all be avoided when using TEV. When using relatively large amount of

Re: [ccp4bb] problem of conventions

2011-03-31 Thread James Holton
I have the 2002 edition, and indeed it only contains space group numbers up to 230. The page numbers quoted by Ian contain space group numbers 17 and 18. Although I am all for program authors building in support for the screwy orthorhombics (as I call them), I should admit that my fuddy-duddy

Re: [ccp4bb] what to do with disordered side chains

2011-03-31 Thread Dale Tronrud
On 3/31/2011 12:52 PM, Jacob Keller wrote: The only advantage of a large, positive, number is that it would create bugs that are more subtle. Although most of the users on this BB probably know more about the software coding, I am surprised that bugs--even subtle ones--would be introduced by

Re: [ccp4bb] Question about GST cleavage

2011-03-31 Thread Nian Huang
I once cleaved a GST tag on the resin using TEV by rocking overnight at 4 C. I would say it is 100% cutting judging from the gel. One thing to add is that the protein bound so tight to the beads that cutting tag is the only way to elute it except by SDS. I haven't had any trouble with TEV and

[ccp4bb] xds question: inverse beam, lots of wedges

2011-03-31 Thread Patrick Loll
We've just collected a number of inverse beam data sets. It turns out the crystals showed little radiation damage, so we have a lot of data: 2 x 360 deg for each crystal, broken up into 30 deg wedges. The collection order went like this: 0-30 deg, 180-210, 30-60, 210-240, etc. Now, assuming no

Re: [ccp4bb] The meaning of B-factor, was Re: [ccp4bb] what to do with disordered side chains

2011-03-31 Thread Zbyszek Otwinowski
Dale Tronrud wrote: While what you say here is quite true and is useful for us to remember, your list is quite short. I can add another 3) The systematic error introduced by assuming full occupancy for all sites. You are right that structural heterogeneity is an additional factor. Se-Met

Re: [ccp4bb] xds question: inverse beam, lots of wedges

2011-03-31 Thread Jan Abendroth
Pat, at least give it a try with the one sweep approach. We have collected plenty of 360deg data sets on a Rigaku system which requires two omega sweeps at phi 0 and 180 deg. These data sets are for in-house phasing. We haven't seen big issues with running XDS over these images as one

Re: [ccp4bb] what to do with disordered side chains

2011-03-31 Thread Sanishvili, Ruslan
Hi All, Notwithstanding the stimulating discussion about the B-factor, I'd like to chime in with my $0.02 on the original question of to build or not to build and what are the rules and standards... and sorry for the lengthy e-mail - I was trying to respond to several comments at once. I thought

[ccp4bb] Jrh input Re: [ccp4bb] what to do with disordered side chains

2011-03-31 Thread Jrh
Dear Ed, Thankyou for this and apologies for late reply. If one has chemical evidence for the presence of residues but these residues are disordered I find the delete atoms option disagreeable. Such a static disorder situation should be described by a high atomic displacement parameter, in my

Re: [ccp4bb] The meaning of B-factor, was Re: [ccp4bb] what to do with disordered side chains

2011-03-31 Thread Zbyszek Otwinowski
Regarding the closing statement about the best solution to poorly ordered side chains: I described in the previous e-mail the probabilistic interpretation of B-factors. In the case of very high uncertainty = poorly ordered side chains, I prefer to deposit the conformer representing maximum a

Re: [ccp4bb] problem of conventions

2011-03-31 Thread Ian Tickle
On Thu, Mar 31, 2011 at 10:43 PM, James Holton jmhol...@lbl.gov wrote: I have the 2002 edition, and indeed it only contains space group numbers up to 230.  The page numbers quoted by Ian contain space group numbers 17 and 18. You need to distinguish the 'IT space group number' which indeed

Re: [ccp4bb] unknown electron density~

2011-03-31 Thread Artem Evdokimov
Try fitting a xylitol molecule in it but watch out for the distortions caused by proximity to symmetry axis. Artem On Thu, Mar 31, 2011 at 1:16 PM, Shu XU xushuh...@gmail.com wrote: Hi, there. I'm refining a 1.76 A structure. The r-work stuck at 21%, rfree is 24% after adding waters. But

Re: [ccp4bb] step refine speed of wincoot - a little drawback of the new interruptible_fit_protein() function in wincoot

2011-03-31 Thread Zhijie Li
Hi Bernhard, I realized this when comparing the functions yesterday. Exactly like what you said, when a user interrupts the process, what he/she wants at the moment is most likely to be going back a few residues instead of starting all over again. I am quite happy to have both interruptible

Re: [ccp4bb] off topic: protease identification

2011-03-31 Thread Artem Evdokimov
This can be very hard to do because quite a few proteases are promiscuous and will cut substrates solely based on masking of the polypeptide within the structure of the protein. Typically these proteases will not stop cutting at a single nick - they often proceed until they can't 'dig into' a

Re: [ccp4bb] problem of conventions

2011-03-31 Thread Santarsiero, Bernard D.
Ian, I think it's amazing that we can program computers to resolve a b c but it would be a major undertaking to store the matrix transformations for 22121 to 21212 and reindex a cell to a standard setting. I was also told that I was lazy to not reindex to the standard setting when I was a grad