Hi,
Does anyone out there actually have a struts2 app running under a grails
project? We have a large app (mainly struts1 actions) but running in struts2
with the s1 plugin and are trying to get it to run under grails.
The app boots up as a spring bean, but struts1 actions fail and error with
Please don't hijack this thread, create a new one, but at the Struts Users
mailing list:
http://struts.apache.org/mail.html
Antonio
2008/2/6, interz12 [EMAIL PROTECTED]:
Hi,
Does anyone out there actually have a struts2 app running under a grails
project? We have a large app (mainly struts1
I think it would be feasible to pull the engine out and use it and then
attempt to put it back in. The key would be that at the end of the road
the next JSP specification dictates a pluggable JSP engine and an
API/configuration for plugging them in. Anyone have any experience with
Jasper?
On Nov 21, 2007 5:14 AM, Ted Husted [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
* Other aspects of the framework might be open to convention-based or
annotation-based binding too, such as type converters.
I see now that XWork already has annotations for type converters
*
On Nov 20, 2007 7:11 PM, Brian Pontarelli [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
I thought that this was not really the same. You couldn't map multiple
actions to a class or handle more different methods for actions. I
haven't looked at the codebehind in a long time, since I've been using
SmartURLs for 6
Well, I was planning on checking out the next JSR, but jcp.org is down.
I'll check back later. If anyone from Sun is on this list, might want to
email the folks that manage that site and let them know it is toast
right now.
-bp
mraible wrote:
I don't think their implementation would be
Works on My Machine (tm)
--- Brian Pontarelli [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Well, I was planning on checking out the next JSR,
but jcp.org is down.
I'll check back later. If anyone from Sun is on this
list, might want to
email the folks that manage that site and let them
know it is toast
Would it be feasible to use Jasper 2 instead?
Historically, it seems that the specifications that were based on a
working technology have been more successful than speculative
specifications. I think everyone involved in the process agrees that
it's much cleaner to create a standard around
Basically, we're still trying to identify what merging SmartURLs into
CodeBehind means.
I just backported a SmartURLs application to the Struts 2.x
CodeBehind/Zero-Config.
I wasn't using any Action annotations, so I didn't miss that feature.
Otherwise, I had to
* change the syntax of the
Am Montag, 19. November 2007 18:55:43 schrieb Brian Pontarelli:
Hopefully that helps clear things up somewhat. If not, feel free to ask
more questions.
Thanks for your detailed answer, I do understand the issues with JSP much
better now.
Oh, and as for your upcoming development around
Here are my thoughts:
AFAICT, the questions then become
* Which Result annotation syntax to support?
** CB uses a .class reference, SU uses a string setting that
corresponds to the Result name.
** CB uses value where SU uses location.
SU because it provides more flexibility with
Piero Sartini wrote:
Am Montag, 19. November 2007 18:55:43 schrieb Brian Pontarelli:
Hopefully that helps clear things up somewhat. If not, feel free to ask
more questions.
Thanks for your detailed answer, I do understand the issues with JSP much
better now.
Excellent!
Oh, and
]
--
View this message in context:
http://www.nabble.com/Struts-2-Plugin-for-Grails--tf4766264.html#a13860894
Sent from the Struts - Dev mailing list archive at Nabble.com.
-
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional
On Nov 20, 2007 11:57 AM, mraible [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
The best thing is to probably see what's on tap for JSP 2.2 and see if we can
get it on the EG's radar.
Matt
If Matt's client were willing to contribute the IP, another way to
proceed would be to open source a proof of concept for the
: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
--
View this message in context:
http://www.nabble.com/Struts-2-Plugin-for-Grails--tf4766264.html#a13862901
Sent from the Struts - Dev mailing list archive at Nabble.com.
-
To unsubscribe, e-mail
--- Don Brown wrote:
On 11/20/07, Brian Pontarelli wrote:
* Should we leverage the action.packages
configuration or a naming convention
for finding action packages?
(I prefer convention)
I'm not so sure about this one. Would we
do something like stripes where we scan
for the
On 11/20/07, Brian Pontarelli [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Here are my thoughts:
AFAICT, the questions then become
* Which Result annotation syntax to support?
** CB uses a .class reference, SU uses a string setting that
corresponds to the Result name.
** CB uses value where SU
On 11/20/07, Dave Newton [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
I'd think that package-level annotations should go in
the package-info.java; that's what it's for, more or
less.
Perfect! I didn't know about that class, hence my hacky workarounds.
Let's definitely use it.
Don
d.
I prefer type safety wherever possible, but the annotation should
probably support both for the rresult type. As for value vs location,
value is more convenient since you can just do:
@Result(/foo.jsp)
for results that use the default result type, and as mentioned,
location isn't the param
For those interested, Mark and I have been collaborating on a proof of
concept for this idea. Details are here:
http://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/S2PLUGINS/Grails+Plugin We
have a simple precompiled groovy controller and GSP up and running.
On Nov 13, 2007 10:38 PM, Vinny [EMAIL
Yep. I fall into that category. How else can you build reusable
components in Struts2? I'm still waiting for the JSP spec is fixed to
support everything from JAR files or modules and make JSP usable outside
J2EE container contexts
is that ever going to happen? (I really hope so)
musachy
Musachy Barroso wrote:
Yep. I fall into that category. How else can you build reusable
components in Struts2? I'm still waiting for the JSP spec is fixed to
support everything from JAR files or modules and make JSP usable outside
J2EE container contexts
is that ever going to happen? (I
This is precisely why I like things like Freemarker and Velocity: You
don't have to wait for the JCP to propose and ratify a standard, and
for the vendors to adopt it.
I hope that Struts 2 continues to strongly support Freemarker. In
fact, I wish they promoted it as the preferred choice.
Am Freitag, 16. November 2007 23:04:37 schrieb Brian Pontarelli:
Yep. I fall into that category. How else can you build reusable
components in Struts2?
Could you please explain why this does not work in s2? I need to build such an
application and was under the impression that it will work with
Piero Sartini wrote:
Am Freitag, 16. November 2007 23:04:37 schrieb Brian Pontarelli:
Yep. I fall into that category. How else can you build reusable
components in Struts2?
Could you please explain why this does not work in s2? I need to build such an
application and was under the
On Nov 19, 2007 9:55 AM, Brian Pontarelli [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
huge-snip/
I'd even go one step further and
abstract out JSPs so that they didn't require a container and provide a
javax package to access and use them outside of containers.
Good luck with this part. ;-) I went down that
On Nov 19, 2007 11:39 AM, Jim Cushing [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
I hope that Struts 2 continues to strongly support Freemarker. In
fact, I wish they promoted it as the preferred choice.
FreeMarker is cool, but I'm still a die-hard Velocity fan :)
Here's the thing: If we started using FreeMarker
-
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
--
View this message in context:
http://www.nabble.com/Struts-2-Plugin-for-Grails--tf4766264.html#a13851330
Sent from the Struts - Dev mailing list archive at Nabble.com
Has anyone tried encapsulating Jasper behind a standalone servlet and
have it load the JSP template independently of the container (a la
Freemarker and Velocity) but not independently of the servlet API
(which would be the second biggest upgrade to the spec).
-Ted.
On Nov 19, 2007 8:06 PM,
On Nov 13, 2007 9:00 AM, Tom Schneider [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
And who says that Struts 2 devs recommend Freemarker? I sure don't. :)
Tom
It's true that there are quite a few hardcore Struts 2 teams that use
FreeMarker or Velocity (for good reason). But, the Apache Struts
Project group
Ted Husted wrote:
On Nov 13, 2007 9:00 AM, Tom Schneider [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
And who says that Struts 2 devs recommend Freemarker? I sure don't. :)
Tom
It's true that there are quite a few hardcore Struts 2 teams that use
FreeMarker or Velocity (for good reason). But, the Apache
Just for completeness I'd think we'd want a GSPResult. Just because
it's slow now, doesn't mean it will be slow in the future. (Look at how
slow freemarker was before we tweaked it) Also, for those looking to
migrate over, if GSP isn't supported, that might be a issue for existing
grails
My unsolicited 2 cents. The idea of integrating Grails scaffolding with
Struts 2 has been bouncing
in my head for few weeks now. The Grails CRUD is a true sweet spot for me
but
Struts still excels when it's time to move beyond a CRUD Action. Getting the
2 frameworks
working together would be
I don't know if we'd really need to support GSPResult in a Struts 2
Plugin. AFAIK, the slowest part of Grails is GSP.
http://tinyurl.com/2298jh
If we were to write a plugin, would it implement the same scaffolding
that Grails has by default? If so, it might be better to use
FreeMarker since that
Mark,
I was reading Getting Started With Grails this weekend and the more I
look at Grails, the more I see your Groovy Works effort fitting into a
Grails mini-porting effort to Struts 2. Much of what you describe is
already in Grails and I think the last thing we need is yet another
groovy
On 11/11/07 5:07 PM, Tom Schneider [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Mark,
I was reading Getting Started With Grails this weekend and the more I
look at Grails, the more I see your Groovy Works effort fitting into a
Grails mini-porting effort to Struts 2. Much of what you describe is
already in
See my comments below:
Mark Menard wrote:
On 11/11/07 5:07 PM, Tom Schneider [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote
I will agree with you, and I've decided I'm done reinventing wheels. So, I'm
game. I'm very pressed for time, but I'm definitely interested in this. I
think a bridge from Java based Struts 2
into a Grails project and have them run,
then be able to start using the Grails controllers or view mixed with S2
stuff.
Mark
On 11/7/07 12:47 PM, Matt Raible [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Has anyone thought about creating a Struts 2 Plugin for Grails?
There's one for Wicket - which proves you don't have
Has anyone thought about creating a Struts 2 Plugin for Grails?
There's one for Wicket - which proves you don't have to use the
default web framework (Spring MVC).
http://grails.org/Wicket+Plugin
IMO, Grails Controllers look a lot more like Struts Actions than they
do Spring MVC. I really
thought about creating a Struts 2 Plugin for Grails?
There's one for Wicket - which proves you don't have to use the
default web framework (Spring MVC).
http://grails.org/Wicket+Plugin
IMO, Grails Controllers look a lot more like Struts Actions than they
do Spring MVC. I really like the productivity
much overlap between what the SWF XML does and what the XWork XML
does.
Tom
On 11/7/07, Matt Raible [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Has anyone thought about creating a Struts 2 Plugin for Grails?
There's one for Wicket - which proves you don't have to use the
default web framework (Spring MVC).
http
How are http://code.google.com/p/s2ss/ and
http://code.google.com/p/groovyworks/ different? Looking at the code
they look very similar. I've been trying to make sure the Plugin
Registry is up to date and has all the plugins that are available, so
I'm wondering if these are 2 separate entries, or
On 11/7/07 1:38 PM, Matt Raible [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
What I'd like is to use Grails to develop my application, but have it
use Struts 2 under-the-covers instead of Spring MVC. As far as code
differences between writing a Spring MVC Grails Controller and a
Struts 2 Grails Controller - I
On 11/7/07 2:58 PM, Tom Schneider [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
How are http://code.google.com/p/s2ss/ and
http://code.google.com/p/groovyworks/ different? Looking at the code
they look very similar. I've been trying to make sure the Plugin
Registry is up to date and has all the plugins that are
On 11/8/07, Matt Raible [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
What I'd like is to use Grails to develop my application, but have it
use Struts 2 under-the-covers instead of Spring MVC. As far as code
differences between writing a Spring MVC Grails Controller and a
Struts 2 Grails Controller - I don't think
45 matches
Mail list logo
