Re: PESO - End Part II

2007-04-26 Thread Eactivist
In a message dated 4/25/2007 6:31:46 P.M. Pacific Daylight Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Marnie, Try 2 is great. Rick = Thanks. Marnie aka Doe ;-) - Warning: I am now filtering my email, so you may be censored.

PESO - End Part II

2007-04-25 Thread Bruce Dayton
Based on comments by the list, I thought I would try a few more things and show you what I had to work with. The story I told is basically how the shot came to be - whether you agree with my thought process or not, that is why I took the shot. The issue I had was harsher lighting than I wanted -

Re: PESO - End Part II

2007-04-25 Thread pnstenquist
I like it as shot. I also like alternates two and three. Paul -- Original message -- From: Bruce Dayton [EMAIL PROTECTED] Based on comments by the list, I thought I would try a few more things and show you what I had to work with. The story I told is basically

Re: PESO - End Part II

2007-04-25 Thread Bob Sullivan
Bruce, I think it's best in black and white - #3. Regards, Bob S. On 4/25/07, Bruce Dayton [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Based on comments by the list, I thought I would try a few more things and show you what I had to work with. The story I told is basically how the shot came to be - whether you

PESO - End Part II

2007-04-25 Thread Walter Hamler
#3, but with a grade higher contrast! If this were on film in BW, I would have printed it on Agfa Brovira 6 :-) Walt -- PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List PDML@pdml.net http://pdml.net/mailman/listinfo/pdml_pdml.net

Re: PESO - End Part II

2007-04-25 Thread frank theriault
On 4/25/07, Bob Sullivan [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Bruce, I think it's best in black and white - #3. Regards, Bob S. I agree. cheers, frank -- Sharpness is a bourgeois concept. -Henri Cartier-Bresson -- PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List PDML@pdml.net

Re: PESO - End Part II

2007-04-25 Thread Tom C
I second that. I think #3 gets your idea cross better than the original image you displayed. Tom C. From: Bob Sullivan [EMAIL PROTECTED] Bruce, I think it's best in black and white - #3. Regards, Bob S. On 4/25/07, Bruce Dayton [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Based on comments by the list, I

Re: PESO - End Part II

2007-04-25 Thread Jack Davis
Much prefer the original image, Bruce. It has a stirring airy sweep to it that is quite nice. Jack --- Bruce Dayton [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Based on comments by the list, I thought I would try a few more things and show you what I had to work with. The story I told is basically how the

Re: PESO - End Part II

2007-04-25 Thread Rick Womer
I like alternative 3 best. Rick --- Bruce Dayton [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Based on comments by the list, I thought I would try a few more things and show you what I had to work with. The story I told is basically how the shot came to be - whether you agree with my thought process or

Re: PESO - End Part II

2007-04-25 Thread Eactivist
In a message dated 4/25/2007 2:02:16 P.M. Pacific Daylight Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Based on comments by the list, I thought I would try a few more things and show you what I had to work with. The story I told is basically how the shot came to be - whether you agree with my thought

Re: PESO - End Part II

2007-04-25 Thread Eactivist
Bruce, I did these in about 10 minutes. I had 10 minutes to spare. :-) I will take them down once I know you have seen them. Some people are going to tell you to go with a straight BW conversion. But in this case, I think you are right, it needs to be punched up.

Re: PESO - End Part II

2007-04-25 Thread Rick Womer
Marnie, Try 2 is great. Rick --- [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Bruce, I did these in about 10 minutes. I had 10 minutes to spare. :-) I will take them down once I know you have seen them. Some people are going to tell you to go with a straight BW conversion. But in this case, I

Re: PESO - End Part II

2007-04-25 Thread Kenneth Waller
The original, as shot gets my vote. Kenneth Waller - Original Message - From: Bruce Dayton [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: PESO - End Part II Based on comments by the list, I thought I would try a few more things and show you what I had to work with. The story I told is basically how

Re: End Part II

2007-04-25 Thread Jay Taylor
Bruce, I also think the original image stands on its own the best for conveying your original idea. The BW works also, but it leaves me wanting to see more tonal range. JayT Bruce Dayton wrote: Based on comments by the list, I thought I would try a few more things and show you what I had

Re: PESO - End Part II

2007-04-25 Thread Boris Liberman
The original and Alternative #3 (bw) are the best. You see, Bruce, to my eye what became of the ocean on the original image you presented did not come across like water. I thought it was a bit more soil, just without any vegetation on it. Actually, I think that the original shot with just a