Re: {S-Scale List} Hinged or solid points to throwbar

2013-10-07 Thread Peter Vanvliet
I used code 83 and all turnouts are solid rail with soldering directly to PC ties(for throwbars). I've had all the track up now for 4 years, and I do several mini operating sessions each week. I've had one rail pop loose, which was like Jim Martin, a bad soldering job. I doesn't take but a few

Re: {S-Scale List} Hinged or solid points to throwbar

2013-10-07 Thread shabbona_rr
are hinged and others are unhinged?? John Armstrong - Original Message - From: pickycat95@... To: S-Scale@yahoogroups.com Sent: Sunday, October 06, 2013 11:56 PM Subject: RE: Re: {S-Scale List} Hinged or solid points to throwbar I soldered all my points

Re: {S-Scale List} Hinged or solid points to throwbar

2013-10-07 Thread Bob Werre
Let me add a few words (?) to what Peter has mentioned. With a few exceptions our modules have small tabs soldered to the web of the rail--they resemble little ears. One of our older members made up a notched form to make these fairly quickly. We then drill a hole for #80 screw or a rivet

RE: Re: {S-Scale List} Hinged or solid points to throwbar

2013-10-07 Thread gcgill
In addition to Jim Martins comments about rail size, I believe turnout number makes a difference too. With a #5 turnout, you have a physically shorter length of rail from the throwbar to the fixed frog than is the case with say a #8. The shorter length puts more stress on the

RE: RE: {S-Scale List} Hinged or solid points to throwbar

2013-10-07 Thread David Heine
Subject: RE: RE: {S-Scale List} Hinged or solid points to throwbar Dave, You must be some sort of engineer to think up an idea like that. Ben Trousdale ---In S-Scale@yahoogroups.com, s-scale@yahoogroups.com wrote: If you wanted to get fancy, you could rig up an automatic system to test

Re: {S-Scale List} Hinged or solid points to throwbar

2013-10-06 Thread Jamie Bothwell
Michael, I have elected to go with soldering the rails to the throw bar, but I don't have years of in use experience. Therefore I would also like to hear from anyone who has had such in place for some time. Jamie Bothwell Curious in Bethlehem, PA On Oct 5, 2013, at 6:26 PM,

Re: {S-Scale List} Hinged or solid points to throwbar

2013-10-06 Thread shabbona_rr
Jamie: The only switches where I soldered the point rails to the throwbar is where I had formed the closure rails to put constant pressure on the throwbar to keep them from stressing the solder joints and pullinf them apart. I wrote this up in the 1/64 Modeling guide a year or so ago. I can't

Re: {S-Scale List} Hinged or solid points to throwbar

2013-10-06 Thread Jim Cheryl Martin
Jamie, Michael...I think the hinged vs soldered throwbar probably depends on whether the point rails are hinged or solid, along with the rail size. My turnouts are made with code 83 rail with solid point rails and soldered throwbars. Code 83 rail doesn't put up a lot of resistance and the few

RE: {S-Scale List} Hinged or solid points to throwbar

2013-10-06 Thread David Heine
, and that was in my pre-handlaid track days. Dave Heine Easton, PA From: S-Scale@yahoogroups.com [mailto:S-Scale@yahoogroups.com] On Behalf Of Jim Cheryl Martin Sent: Sunday, October 06, 2013 9:13 PM To: S-Scale@yahoogroups.com Subject: Re: {S-Scale List} Hinged or solid points to throwbar

RE: RE: {S-Scale List} Hinged or solid points to throwbar

2013-10-06 Thread pickycat95
, 2013 9:13 PMTo: S-Scale@yahoogroups.comSubject: Re: {S-Scale List} Hinged or solid points to throwbar Jamie, Michael...I think the hinged vs soldered throwbar probably depends on whether the point rails are hinged or solid, along with the rail size. My turnouts are made with code 83 rail with solid

RE: Re: {S-Scale List} Hinged or solid points to throwbar

2013-10-06 Thread pickycat95
I soldered all my points to the throw bar and all the points werehinged for bothcode 100 and code 125 rail. I made the hinges for 125 rail out of SHS insulated joiners and for 100 rail out of PECO insulated joiners. The throw bars weremade of PC boardwith a gap in the copper foil.

Re: Re: {S-Scale List} Hinged or solid points to throwbar

2013-10-06 Thread John
Does all this add up to a group of S gaugers where some are hinged and others are unhinged?? John Armstrong - Original Message - From: pickyca...@yahoo.com To: S-Scale@yahoogroups.com Sent: Sunday, October 06, 2013 11:56 PM Subject: RE: Re: {S-Scale List} Hinged or solid

Re: {S-Scale List} Hinged or solid points to throwbar

2013-10-06 Thread scale S only
Hi Ben-- I have had that happen too, but a bit of plastic “rub strip” glued to the tie side keeps the assembly from walking too far to be obnoxious.I also solder a tie bar of inverted rail across the points (or another piece of PC strip) the next tie space over from the throwbar towards