Re: [WikiEN-l] Building a community or building an encyclopedia?

2010-10-18 Thread Carcharoth
Read this a few days ago, and thought it was really good. Wanted to say that, even if there isn't much more to add. I particularly liked the last bit: We're an educational institution in two senses: we write educational material for the world in general, and we educate each other. Carcharoth On

Re: [WikiEN-l] Building a community or building an encyclopedia?

2010-10-18 Thread David Gerard
On 17 October 2010 06:22, David Goodman dgoodma...@gmail.com wrote: We're an educational institution in two senses: we write educational material forv the world in general, and we educate each other. I strongly suggest you start a Wikimedia-related blog and crosspost posts like this to it,

Re: [WikiEN-l] Building a community or building an encyclopedia?

2010-10-18 Thread Fred Bauder
On 17 October 2010 06:22, David Goodman dgoodma...@gmail.com wrote: We're an educational institution in two senses: we write educational material forv the world in general, and we educate each other. I strongly suggest you start a Wikimedia-related blog and crosspost posts like this to it,

Re: [WikiEN-l] Building a community or building an encyclopedia?

2010-10-16 Thread Charles Matthews
On 15/10/2010 22:36, MuZemike wrote: snip That comes to my question regarding whether or not we are here to build an online community or an online encyclopedia. Should we focus outwards toward the reading/viewing audience, or should we focus inwards towards the editors? It was settled

Re: [WikiEN-l] Building a community or building an encyclopedia?

2010-10-16 Thread Marc Riddell
On 15/10/2010 22:36, MuZemike wrote: snip That comes to my question regarding whether or not we are here to build an online community or an online encyclopedia. Should we focus outwards toward the reading/viewing audience, or should we focus inwards towards the editors? on 10/16/10

Re: [WikiEN-l] Building a community or building an encyclopedia?

2010-10-16 Thread Charles Matthews
On 16/10/2010 15:23, Marc Riddell wrote: On 15/10/2010 22:36, MuZemike wrote: snip That comes to my question regarding whether or not we are here to build an online community or an online encyclopedia. Should we focus outwards toward the reading/viewing audience, or should we focus

Re: [WikiEN-l] Building a community or building an encyclopedia?

2010-10-16 Thread David Goodman
More than maintaining the articles,and more than maintaining the group, the focus should be on maintain the continual and increasing development of new editors and new articles--not just as content creators, but as gnomes, and techies, and admins. The excitement of working here has not just been

[WikiEN-l] Building a community or building an encyclopedia?

2010-10-15 Thread MuZemike
I get this feeling sometimes that some people are more interested in building a community on Wikipedia rather than helping to construct an encyclopedia. I tend to think that there is a notion which existed upon Wikipedia's founding: Always leave something undone. Whenever you write a page,

Re: [WikiEN-l] Building a community or building an encyclopedia?

2010-10-15 Thread Fred Bauder
Focus on the task is the work involved. It is only with great difficulty that a group can develop the skill necessary to deal successfully with the dynamics inherent in group work and get something done. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wilfred_Bion#Basic_assumptions and his book Experiences in