From: H Veeder 

 

Suppose epicatalysis can cycle between hydrogen and shrunken hydrogen instead 
of just between H2 and H.

 

That would be the logical progression to Mills’ view, especially if UV was 
present - except RM sez there is no shuttling, just a one-way, but strongly 
bonded shrunken state. 

 

If there is to be net gain from any kind of chemical asymmetry, it seems likely 
that a shuttling to f/H and then back again, rather than or in addition to 
atomic and molecular asymmetry, is likely – since the physical evidence for f/H 
is slim.

 

In terms of the long mean free-path, many of Mills earlier experiments were run 
at vacuum. For Sheehan - the free path is not really all that long - about a 
micron and about 10^17 atoms/cc. Mills often uses a stronger vacuum which is 
less populated. 

 

Definitely, Sheehan should look for UV emission. 

 

Reply via email to