In a message dated 10/2/10 2:41:40 PM, [email protected] writes:

> My guess is Gissing was making a basic error in logic: He noticed many 
> would-be artists studied to no avail. From which he dim-wittedly inferred 
> all 
> artists study to no avail. 
> 

Or he may have believed in "genius" and the idea that it is a gift given to 
few and can't be studied for.   My money would be on genius.   His initial 
sentence about principles being   discussed vehemently when practice is at a 
low ebb is nonsense-argument   is always freely indulged in by all.
Kate Sullivan

Reply via email to