On Thu, 17 Jun 2004, Yan King Yin wrote:
I think currently AGI is going through a fermenting stage before a dominant design will emerge. This will require a lot of work, and it is
I can understand how AI researchers always believe in the eventual success of their projects, but it is also quite *predictable* that only one AGI group will achieve market domination. This outcome will be devastating to other groups, as history has shown. It's not sensible to assume that every group can somehow carve a niche in the market. If we
Why not? These statements seem to fly in the face of historical precedent for most technologies There are an infinite range of solutions to this problem, and there is no incentive for the entire world to choose one solution (unlike certain technologies, ie communication and data storage protocols).
This is a market entirely composed of niches.
Not that your consortium is a bad idea, but I think you are basing this on some dangerously speculative (and IMO baldly incorrect) assumptions.
don�t try to collaborate to capture market value, it is actually very likely that many groups will not be able to sustain their research. And it is also very predictable that some later startups will achieve dominance because they have not incurred early research costs. In short, the outcome will be very chaotic.
This is usually the case in new technological domains. The first innovators get wiped out by the next generation that learns from their success.
Nothing wrong with this (apart from being unfair), just capitalism at work. Someone will steal your ideas and implement them in a better way than you have.
-Brad
-------
To unsubscribe, change your address, or temporarily deactivate your subscription, please go to http://v2.listbox.com/member/[EMAIL PROTECTED]
