On 3/28/07, Youness Alaoui <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > ok, now my comments... > 1 - the skin looks nicer now, much more simple! i like it too!
> the CL : > 2 - the CL top is still white which is too different from the low CL... +1 > 4 - the buddy icons skin color is too different, looks nice, maybe only need > to get used to it, but is it > necessary to have skin there ? I don't agree, they're great. > 5- the expand (not collapse) group button doesn't look too good because the > arrow is not centered.. i would prefer being moved down of about 1px > 6 - the box around the group's name is a bit non centered too, too much space > below and not enough above... but > I like it 'slim'.. me too the space between groups amsn & friends is a bit to small (+1px), and it's different from the space between groups friends & Offline (which can be understood), but looks weird on that screenshot. Maybe if the group isn't collapsed, it's better. > 7 - the dp frame in the top CL doesn't give the right feeling because you > already have white padding in your own > DP, so maybe show us what it looks like with the defaut aMSN DP (which is > another pixmap we'd like to see) +1 > 9 - the star in vivia's nick is weird, I guess you have your own smiley set, > we'd like to see that, I think we > should keep one smiley set (the current one) and not change it, people hate > changes (especially for the smileys > that we're all so used to see) i would love to see the smileys you used with sheeny deluxe (the first version) (and having them in big size, but i may be the only one to like that :s) > 10 - the grey status isn't contrasted enough with the bg.. it's hard to read > (a little) #333333 maybe better (i love that color :D ) > 11 - would be nice to have a VERY light, kind of like a watermark, icon of > aMSN in the BG of the CL like the one from sheeny-deluxe. > the CW : > 13 - humm.. looks like your DP has a very small padding, I thought it was > bigger.. so it means the fram on the > Cl is really with such a big padding? then it doesn't look good as it is.. yep, need to see it with a 96x96 DP Maybe it'd better if there's no border around the DP > 14 - the paddings everywhere (status bar, buttonbar, etc..) is too big, I > hate it and I don't understand why > almost all skins use big padding there, I like it when it's pad=0 or pad=2 > maybe.. +1 > 15 - the tabs are too big, make them smaller please i don't know what to think about the size needs some testing :) > 16 - I like the arrow on the selected tab, it changes from the way it is > now... but maybe make the arrow more > noticeable.. or even do it like windows tabbar, have a 'sunken' relief or > something.. but arrow is good! +1 > 17 - the buttonbar's buttons are black/white.. I don't know if I like that or > not.. with the bg amd tabs, it > makes too much grey in the window I think It seems they are disabled. I think those icons should be colored. > 18 - nice on the coloring of the buttons when hovered... > 19 - the arrow for the show/hide dp looks like the group collapse/expand, but > I don't like it too much, i think > a vertical bar is better than a one small button.. +1 I don't like that much the pixmap behind "To: Bæåst" i would prefer a darker color like the one on sheeny-deluxe. The scrollbar should be grey/black&white. The nudge button seems to be 1px higher. The border on the bottom of CW where there's "You can't chat with yourself" is too dark. About shipping it, i think it should be as i may prefer that skin :D However, having 2 skins shipped would make the packages bigger. We'll have to check that. That's all for now, but it's a very good work! Thank you. -- Boris FAURE (aka billiob) mail, msn : [EMAIL PROTECTED] No trees were killed in the sending of this message. However, a large number of electrons were terribly agitated. ------------------------------------------------------------------------- Take Surveys. Earn Cash. Influence the Future of IT Join SourceForge.net's Techsay panel and you'll get the chance to share your opinions on IT & business topics through brief surveys-and earn cash http://www.techsay.com/default.php?page=join.php&p=sourceforge&CID=DEVDEV _______________________________________________ Amsn-devel mailing list Amsn-devel@lists.sourceforge.net https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/amsn-devel
