Hi Elvis, > > If we work on a new policy proposal, maybe we > can remove DN for everything else but ARIN incoming IPs (for as long as ARIN > will keep DN in their policy) and still be compatible with RIPE and ARIN > policies regarding Inter-RIR transfers.
I think that would cause a nasty policy fragmentation effect. I believe we should make a holistic decision about DN and stick to it. It's either something we believe is a good idea, or it's not. At the moment however we appear to be in a position of: "We don't think DN is a good idea and we'd do away with it entirely if only ARIN would continue to transfer addresses to the APNIC region" Dean _______________________________________________ apnic-talk mailing list [email protected] http://mailman.apnic.net/mailman/listinfo/apnic-talk
