On 7/23/2008 3:26 AM India Time, _Vinayakam Murugan_ wrote: >> Oh God. It is first time I came to know thru you that this song could be >> a dig on Salman. Hmm. I should have guessed that. Nice catch. > > It was a big controversy with the news being splashed all around. > Aamir even clarified that it is not a dig at Salman as Salman can > dance very well
:-) politically correct. >> :-) You forgot the Mangal Pandey mess? > > I thought Main Vari Vari and Takey Takey were classics. The title song > versions were decent. music was good but how the film butchered the songs. I particular miss Rasiya. What a lovely Purabiya lyrics. "dil dhadka kya koi danka baanjega." one of the better ones of Javed. And they sliced it half. >> Keep your fingers crossed. All these Aamir and all others are >> self-absorbed Narcissus and they wouldn't care for ARR or anybody when >> it really matters. Even Mani dropped Thayya Thayya. Even Aamir chopped >> songs and deleted songs in JTJYN itself. It all depends on what suits >> themselves at a particular time. > > True, the film's interest has to be paramount. In JTJYN, I think that dance song (Kahin To???) with Sushant kissing Aditi, and Jay staring getting uncomfortable was sliced, but I think it would have a better impact if it had been full. That build up of Imran's emotions on seeing Aditi dancing with someone else so intimately would have been very effective. With the sliced songs, the discomfort or anger of Imran came so suddenly as a surprised. And, the newly added Jaane tu mera kya hai, is shabbily shot, so much that even lip sync is missing between song and actress at places (though the other effects were good). I mean they mess up films in several ways, and they do it under the heading of "interest of the film". :-) > >> btw, did anybody notice that new launches of starsons and stardaughters >> have mostly gone to Anu Malik. But still, Aamir took ARR for this launch >> of Imran and ARR lived up to that also. That is a good step. I foresee >> more new launches having ARR's music nowonwards. > No comments on Anu but quality lasts. :) I don't know but I guess that ARR's signature putting off some people might have been major irritant for the newbie's dad who didn't want to take any risk for his son's and daughter's first film, so he went for a more safer Anu who didn't have any signature Now, that ARR has gone hit with and without his signature in JTJYN, he would be a better choice for newbies' dads. Anu's music - howsoever hit it might become, doesn't get respect and doesn't last. > > Warm Regards > ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ > Vinayak -- V
