+1. I have both the original for travel and the deluxe for home play- great replay value with the alternate characters, simple, short and thematic!
As far as Carcassonne is concerned, isn't there a variant that's better for two players? My 2p experience with vanilla Carc was very lackluster. Hive's great, Catan the card game too but rather long (way too long for lunch- same goes for Spaceship Catan). Apparenty In the Year of the Dragon and Citadels are also fun 2p. Best, Julien On Dec 30, 5:01 pm, "[email protected]" <[email protected]> wrote: > The original LOTR: Confrontation is quite small, portable and easily > playable in 30 minutes. Probably worth getting if your partner likes > the subject matter and bluffing style games. > > On Dec 30, 7:57 am, Brian <[email protected]> wrote: > > > I know there are a couple GeekLists that help with this, and they've > > been helpful. I just thought I'd get more input for my situation. > > > I've been trying to find another good game for 2 (maybe 3) players > > that could be played over lunch that's got a little depth, > > replayability, etc. Plus hopefully quick setup and not take up too > > much space. Maybe that's an unreasonable list of requirements. > > Here's my short list: > > > Catan: the Card Game > > Carcasonne > > Hive > > Battle Line > > Race for the Galaxy > > Stone Age > > > I initially thought the Catan card game was 'Catan light', but after > > reading about it a bit on bgg it looks like it's fairly complex - not > > that that's a problem, just not what I had assumed. I bought this > > over the holidays, played it once, it was OK. Gotta give it more > > plays. (I really like regular Catan:Cities & Knights but > > unfortunately my main play group does not) > > > I've only played Carcasonne twice. First time was with 3 people and I > > came away with it not crazy about it, don't remember why. I played it > > once over the holidays with a 2-player game and like it much more. > > Not sure why I came away with a different impression. It seemed light > > and quick, but with enough interesting decisions. > > > I've had Hive and BattleLine recommended personally but haven't played > > either yet, except Hive once online to see how it works. > > > I'm not sure how good those last 2 are for 2 players. I've only > > played RftG once and it was painful but I still like the potential. I > > don't remember where I saw it recommended for 2 players, is it? I've > > played San Juan several times, and a couple times with only 2 players. > > I really didn't like it with 2, and don't like it much more with 3-4 > > anymore. I'm not trying to re-ignite any SanJuan vs RftG discussion. > > > Stone Age, haven't yet played, even on BSW. Heard it's like Agricola- > > lite. Is it any good for 2? > > > Thanks --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "BGG Down" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/BGG_down?hl=en -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
