<< Why do you support Israel? Their words speak of peace, but their actions

speak of continued agression. Given the enthusiasm with which Israel

launches strike after strike, killing several Palestinians for every killed

Israeli, they give the impression that the Israeli regime is intend on going

on till there are no Palestinians left alive. >>


With all due respect, and not intending to call anyone names, this is one of 
the most disgraceful and intellectually indefensible statements I've ever 
heard. The one thing Israelis want more than anything else is for the whole 
Palestinian problem to GO AWAY so they can live normal lives. Yes, there are 
some settlers who want to hold on to the West Bank more than they want peace. 
Yes, there are a few lunatic followers of the late Meyer Kahane who call 
Arabs animals and want to expel them from all of Israel. Yes, Ariel Sharon is 
a murderer who should be voted out of office. But to say that the Israelis 
are enthusiastic about killing Palestinians or that they want to continue 
doing so until all the Palestinians are dead is coming perilously close to 
the "blood libel" (which, by the way, various Muslim clerics still continue 
to spread to this very day) and shows a total ignorance of Judaism, which 
reveres life. The tragedy of Israel today is that Jews are being forced to be 
killers, which goes against every ingrained tradition of Judaism. 

Most Israelis want to be rid of any responsibility for the Palestinians; they 
just have no idea how to bring this about. Continuing terrorist attacks on 
civilians scare them out of their minds; the fact that groups like Hamas can 
get away with these attacks and that the Palestinian Authority either cannot 
or will not stop them does nothing to allay those fears.

Nobody ever called for killing every Palestinian; within living memory, 
people actually tried to murder every single Jew on the planet. What the 
Sharon government is doing now is wrong; but that will change, and soon too, 
I hope. Why don't you tell Hamas to stop doing what it is doing, too? (I know 
why - because Hamas will not listen and there is nothing anyone can do to 
make them listen. Whereas Israel is amenable to various kinds of pressure.)




Tom Beck


"I always knew I'd see the first man on the Moon. I didn't realize I'd also 
see the last." - Jerry Pournelle

Reply via email to