>
> You still miss the issue. The argument for not changing is that (a) few
>people feel the need for the change, (b) the kernel developers are
>working at other things they think are important, and (c) any major
>change like this would require user education, changes in configuration,
>and don't belong in a stable release. Maybe this will be in 2.6 someday.
>
Something Must Change so that writing to ATAPI CD's in all manner can be done.
It looks like there is a real problem here, getting to the person that keeps cdrecord
from working.
Where is the blame to be laid?
cdrecord ?
ide-scsi ?
kernel options ?
OR Tell us dumb users how to make the packages come together
>
> You know, my music sounds fine, I guess I just can't hear them. In
>case you missed the point, data CDs and playing music work fine on IDE
>without all the stuff you consider important.
The real point is that Writing to the CD-RW DOES NOT WORK for everyone
Seach dejanews on ide-scsi Errors and see the hunders of posts were unknow command
errors abound
>>
>> >> >>You are saying the same thing as Alan Cox:
>> >> >>
>> >> >> Let us keep the bugs in ide-scsi & the SCSI cdrom driver on Linux
>because
>> >> >> I do not realize any problem for _my_ personal work.
>
> More to the point, because there is no compelling reason to change it,
>and problems described above which result from it.
See above.
There must be a reason somewhere why CD-R does not work with ide drives
>> So you are going to convince me to stop with my attempt to make Linux easier
>> to use and just forward any mail to you and Alan. I hope that at least then
>> you will realize that there is a problem that needs to be solved.
Is there enough votes in to make that point? That there really is a problem with
the CD recording schema. I do believe there is, and the real question is who will
admit that
some one needs to fix it.
--
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]
