Dear all, Yes, this "Subproperty of" actually reflects a former state of the model, in which the range of R20 was E5 Event. It was me who asked that the range be relaxed to E2 Temporal Entity, as the fist example for F21 Recording Work clearly refers to the recording of a condition state, but I overlooked the fact that this conflicts with the "Subproperty of" statement. I think this could be solved by declaring two "Subproperty of shortcut of" statements, on the same pattern as for R65 recorded aspects of, one resulting in E5 Event, and one resulting in E3 Condition State. Best wishes, Patrick
Message de : "Athina Kritsotaki" <[email protected]> 19/02/2015 14:26 Envoyé par : "Crm-sig" <[email protected]> Pour [email protected] Copie Objet [Crm-sig] new CIDOC CRM issue New CIDOC CRM (and not FRBR) Issue Dear all, The FRBR property R20 recorded with Domain:F29 Recording Event and Range: E2 Temporal Entity is declared as a subproperty of E7 Activity: P15 was influenced by (influenced):E5 Event: P9B forms part of: E5 Event: P9 consists of: E5 Event. This path makes sense up to the …influenced by –part. The range of this influence can be anything (E1 CRM Entity) but not an E5 event (which is a subclass of E2 and not a superclass) and additionally, a part-whole relationship (P9 consists of) can not be assigned to E2 Temporal Entities (only to E4 Periods)-as it is declared in CRM. Consequently, the question is how can we describe events having as parts states? (because it seems that this was the intention to capture with this property: Recording Events recorded: Temporal Entity (and the subproperty mentioned above). RGs Athina Kritsotaki ---------------------------- Athina Kritsotaki Information System Laboratory Institute of Computer Science Foundation of Research & Technology e-mail:[email protected] Tel: 2810 391639 _______________________________________________ Crm-sig mailing list [email protected] http://lists.ics.forth.gr/mailman/listinfo/crm-sig Exposition De Rouge et de Noir. Les vases grecs de la collection de Luynes - jusqu'au 31 octobre 2015 - BnF - Richelieu Avant d'imprimer, pensez à l'environnement.
