Hi Christian,

> I sat down this weekend trying to import an image from applications such as
> Inkscape, Karbon16 and Xara Extreme into OpenOffice. The results you find
> here:
> http://www.linuxrising.org/importsvg/

Thanks for your really beautiful benchmark image!

Unfortunately, you write on your evaluation page:

> So the first thing I tried was importing the SVG into OpenOffice.
> Turns out there is still no native SVG support in OpenOffice. Found an
> importfilter online
> [http://www.ipd.uni-karlsruhe.de/~hauma/svg-import/], but trying to
> import using it just cause OpenOffice to segfault.

That's really a pity. As somebody else has noticed, your image opens
perfectly well with the SVG import filter installed.

But, if the import filter does not work for you: there is also a command
line version of the conversion program. You may give it a try. It's
available from the same page. It converts *.svg directly into
OpenDocument/Draw (*.odg) without any dependency on OpenOffice.org. It's
written in pure Java 5 and available in source code also.

The result looks better than I had expected. Ok, OpenOffice.org Draw
does  no anti-aliasing and the green background gradient has a slightly
to high intensity - but even the native SVG renderers in your benchmark
seem to interpret the image somewhat differently.

Btw: These gradient issues could be fixed easily in the filter, if only
OpenOffice.org would implement the *full* OpenDocument spec! The filter
does its best to convert into an OpenDocument flavor that can be
displayed by OpenOffice.org.

I agree that SVG import - or at least SVG display is an important issue
for OpenOffice.org. But comparing native SVG rendering libraries and
editors as libsvg and Inkscape against a business charting tool like
Draw is somewhat unfair.


Best regards
Bernhard

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to