Hi Chris,

the main reason for me to "give it away" is the maintenance of the module.
As we did not shine in the past for our in-depth expertice of netty (not 
looking at someone here...) it is a bit wanky and always in the danger of 
becoming "abandoned" : )

Julian

Am 14.08.19, 12:04 schrieb "Christofer Dutz" <christofer.d...@c-ware.de>:

    Hi Julian,
    
    a strong +1 for keeping it here. For the raw socket stuff I think I had 
even added the "raw-socket" module to "utils" which should become a netty 
transport you could use outside of PLC4X.
    And then a "plc4j-protocol-driver-base-raw-socket" which sort of is the 
glue to bring that module into our world. 
    I think the directory structure could use some cleaning up, but how about 
doing it that way for the serial stuff ...
    
    Create the PLC4X agnostic library in "utlils" and update the existing 
plc4j-protocol-driver-base-serial module to use that.
    
    Of course, if an external project wants to use it, they can and it's a 
little group-id fame for Toddy.
    
    Chris
    
    
    
    Am 14.08.19, 11:54 schrieb "Julian Feinauer" <j.feina...@pragmaticminds.de>:
    
        Hi all,
        
        As some of you may know (not sure if it was on the list) I hacked 
together a bridge between Netty 4 and Serial Port connectivity.
        I opened a discussion on the (somehow inofficial and half-deprecated) 
Netty dev list and already got a response from Norman (main maintainer of 
Netty, I think), see [1].
        They would prefer to have the code not there (I would prefer to have it 
there) so I will create a module in PLC4X to host it there for now.
        Although it could even be in a separate repo (bc it could be used by 
others then PLC4X) its easiest to have it here with LEGAL and all that stuff 
(than in a separate repo of mine or so).
        
        Any comments or objections (other than if I look at the raw sockets 
impl) ?
        
        Julian
        
        PS.: Yes Chris, I’ll look at raw sockets when I’m done with that :P
        
        [1] https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/netty/VkuE-IbURvc
        
    
    

Reply via email to