Antonio Petrelli wrote:
David H. DeWolf ha scritto:
I have attempted to take into account all of the feedback which has
been provided for the tiles graduation proposal and have documented it
on the Wiki. I've attempted to do so in an unbiased fashion and
encourage you to update any sections you feel need to be modified.
At this point, it seems to me as though there are 2 different
decisions at hand.
1) Is Tiles ready for Graduation
- The consensus seems to be yes
2) Where Should Tiles Graduate to?
2a) If it is to stay in the Struts family temporarily, should it be as
a subproject or as a part of the struts2-tiles-plugin.
I'll keep the discussion open for a couple more days and then, barring
any significant discussions that need to get hashed out, propose a
vote in order to finalize this decision.
Instead of creating a Jakarta subproject for web components, why don't
we open a TLP for web components and then add Tiles?
Since there are topic-based projects (think of ws and logging), this
would be a nice place to put web stuff, and I suppose that could be a
REAL umbrella project.
I know that it costs the double comparing to the opening a TLP for
Tiles, but I think that the community and the users can identify
correctly all web components in a single place.
If we're going to have to leave struts to make the release, then I
agree. A TLP umbrella for web components is the only way to do it and
immediately have the community I'd feel comfortable with.
I still would like a temporary graduation to struts so we can perform a
release, but I'm also willing to start working on a TLP proposal at the
same time. Perhaps if we start moving in that direction, others would
be more apt to see we're serious about the move and let us graduate
temporarily :)
What other apache subprojects would fit under that TLP? What other
non-apache projects?
David
Just my 2 eurocents
Antonio
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
