dev
Thread
Date
Earlier messages
Later messages
Messages by Date
2026/03/16
Re: [I] Logout is accessible via GET, enabling forced-logout attacks (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
Re: [I] Logout is accessible via GET, enabling forced-logout attacks (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
Re: [PR] Logout is a POST (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
Re: [PR] Bump stylelint-config-standard from 37.0.0 to 40.0.0 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
Re: [PR] Bump stylelint-config-standard from 37.0.0 to 40.0.0 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
Re: [PR] Bump stylelint-config-standard from 37.0.0 to 40.0.0 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
Re: [PR] Bump stylelint from 16.14.1 to 17.4.0 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
Re: [PR] Bump stylelint from 16.14.1 to 17.4.0 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
Re: [PR] Bump stylelint from 16.14.1 to 17.4.0 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
Re: [PR] Bump stylelint from 16.14.1 to 17.4.0 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
Re: [PR] Bump aiosqlite from 0.21.0 to 0.22.1 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
Re: [PR] Bump aiosqlite from 0.21.0 to 0.22.1 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
Re: [PR] Bump https://github.com/oxc-project/mirrors-oxlint from v1.55.0 to 1.56.0 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
Re: [PR] Bump https://github.com/oxc-project/mirrors-oxlint from v1.55.0 to 1.56.0 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
[I] Expand SBOM support (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
Re: [I] RAO / maven upload only works for single release artifact (+classifiers) (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
[PR] Bump aiosqlite from 0.21.0 to 0.22.1 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
[PR] Bump stylelint from 16.14.1 to 17.4.0 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
[PR] Bump https://github.com/oxc-project/mirrors-oxlint from v1.55.0 to 1.56.0 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
[PR] Bump pydantic-core from 2.41.5 to 2.42.0 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
[PR] Bump stylelint-config-standard from 37.0.0 to 40.0.0 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
Re: [I] We can add `editorconfig-checker` with pre-commit: a tool to verify that your files are in harmony with your `.editorconfig` (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
Re: [I] Dependabot now supports pre-commit hooks (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
Re: [PR] Add `pre-commit` hooks to dependabot.yml (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
[PR] Add `pre-commit` hooks to dependabot.yml (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
[PR] #776 - implement 50k character limit for vote comment and support passing form errors through a cache in the form module instead of via flash in the session (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
Re: [I] Support `SafeCommittee` taint tracking (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
Re: [I] Support `SafeCommittee` taint tracking (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
Re: [I] Support `SafeCommittee` taint tracking (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
Re: [I] Record latest presence, hash, and classification data in the database (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
Re: [I] Classification is inconsistent (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
[I] Record latest presence, hash, and classification data in the database (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
[I] Record the check version number in the check result table (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
Re: [I] Vote content fields lack length and content validation (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
Re: [I] Support `SafeCommittee` taint tracking (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
Re: [I] Support `SafeCommittee` taint tracking (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
Test message - please ignore
Alastair McFarlane
2026/03/16
Re: [I] Support `SafeCommittee` taint tracking (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
Re: [I] Vote tabulation - UID/email detection doesn't work when sent from external email with strict DKIM settings (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/16
Re: [PR] Fix typo in Markdown file (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/15
Re: [I] Does the Docker container run as the root user ? Implement a Non-Root User (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/15
Re: [I] Does the Docker container run as the root user ? Implement a Non-Root User (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/15
Re: [I] Support `SafeCommittee` taint tracking (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/15
Re: [PR] Adding docs for cascading (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/15
Re: [I] Vote content fields lack length and content validation (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/15
[I] Support Mermaid charts in the documentation pages (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/15
Re: [PR] Adding docs for cascading (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/15
Re: [PR] Adding docs for cascading (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/15
Re: [PR] Adding docs for cascading (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/15
Re: [PR] Moving asfquart doc into `atr/docs` (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/15
Re: [PR] Moving asfquart doc into `atr/docs` (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/15
Re: [PR] Fix typo in Markdown file (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/15
Re: [PR] Adding a pydantic json schema for output (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/15
Re: [I] ATR OpenAPI viewer 500 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/15
Re: [PR] Adding a pydantic json schema for output (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/15
Re: [I] Vote tabulation - UID/email detection doesn't work when sent from external email with strict DKIM settings (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/15
Re: [PR] Bump pyjwt from 2.11.0 to 2.12.0 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/15
Re: [PR] Bump pyjwt from 2.11.0 to 2.12.0 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/15
Re: [I] Does the Docker container run as the root user ? Implement a Non-Root User (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/15
Re: [I] Does the Docker container run as the root user ? Implement a Non-Root User (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/14
[I] We can add `editorconfig-checker` with pre-commit: a tool to verify that your files are in harmony with your `.editorconfig` (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/14
[I] Dependabot now supports pre-commit hooks (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/14
[I] Does the Docker container run as the root user ? Implement a Non-Root User (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/14
[PR] Fix typo in Markdown file (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/14
[I] pre-commit: we can add `checkmake` a linter for Makefiles. It scans Makefiles for potential issues based on configurable rules. (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/13
[PR] Bump pyjwt from 2.11.0 to 2.12.0 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/13
[PR] Adding a pydantic json schema for output; fixes #883 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/13
Re: [I] ATR OpenAPI viewer 500 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/13
[I] ATR OpenAPI viewer 500 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/13
Re: [I] Subscribe to pubsub for LDAP and use it to inform authorisation decisions (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/13
Re: [I] Turning off the global check result cache does not work (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/13
Re: [I] Turning off the global check result cache does not work (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/13
[I] All emails queried from LDAP on every vote tabulation (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/13
Re: [I] Vote tabulation - UID/email detection doesn't work when sent from external email with strict DKIM settings (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/13
Re: [I] SVN import URL lacks scheme validation — SSRF and local file read risk (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/13
Re: [I] Session handling refactor parent (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/13
Re: [I] Turning off the global check result cache does not work (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/13
[I] Allow more filenames in top level checks (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/13
Re: [I] Turning off the global check result cache does not work (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/13
Re: [VOTE] Release Tooling 0.1
Alastair McFarlane
2026/03/13
Re: [I] Remove `LICENSE` and `NOTICE` checks for binary packages (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/13
Re: [I] Remove `LICENSE` and `NOTICE` checks for binary packages (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/13
Re: [I] Remove `LICENSE` and `NOTICE` checks for binary packages (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/13
[I] Turning off the global check result cache does not work (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/13
Re: [VOTE] Release Tooling 0.1
Alastair McFarlane via dev
2026/03/13
Re: [VOTE] Release Tooling 0.1
Alastair McFarlane via dev
2026/03/13
[I] Classification is inconsistent (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/13
Re: [I] Remove `LICENSE` and `NOTICE` checks for binary packages (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/13
[I] Make license header checks more lenient (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/13
Re: [I] Remove `LICENSE` and `NOTICE` checks for binary packages (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/13
[I] Remove `LICENSE` and `NOTICE` checks for binary packages (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/13
[VOTE] Release Tooling 0.1
arm
2026/03/13
Re: [VOTE] Release Tooling 0.1
arm
2026/03/13
Re: [I] Vote content fields lack length and content validation (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/13
Re: [I] Vote content fields lack length and content validation (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/13
Re: [I] Add temporal validation helper to `TrustedPublisherPayload` model (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/13
Re: [I] Apply URL encoding to mailing list API query parameters (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/13
Re: [I] SVN import URL lacks scheme validation — SSRF and local file read risk (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/13
Re: [I] Add temporal validation helper to `TrustedPublisherPayload` model (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [PR] Logout is a POST (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
[PR] Logout is a POST (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] SVN import URL lacks scheme validation — SSRF and local file read risk (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
[I] Documents GitHub * workflow paths (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Add temporal validation helper to `TrustedPublisherPayload` model (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Document how to become a Trusted Publishing project (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Document how to become a Trusted Publishing project (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Document how to become a Trusted Publishing project (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [PR] Moving asfquart doc into `atr/docs` (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Add temporal validation helper to `TrustedPublisherPayload` model (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
[GH] Moving asfquart doc into `atr/docs` (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Move extracted directories out of the cache directory (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
[PR] Moving asfquart doc into `atr/docs` (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Make extracted archive directories immutable (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Make extracted archive directories immutable (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Move extracted directories out of the cache directory (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Move extracted directories out of the cache directory (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Enforce MAX_CONTENT_LENGTH and add file upload size limits across all HTTP entry points (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Enforce MAX_CONTENT_LENGTH and add file upload size limits across all HTTP entry points (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Fix Content-Type mismatch — plain text error responses served as text/html in asfquart (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Fix Content-Type mismatch — plain text error responses served as text/html in asfquart (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Handle session isolation for mixed authentication methods (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Handle session isolation for mixed authentication methods (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
[I] Session handling refactor parent (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Apply URL encoding to mailing list API query parameters (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Move test routes to a separate blueprint (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Vote content fields lack length and content validation (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Move test routes to a separate blueprint (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Automatically delete unfinished releases (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] SVN import URL lacks scheme validation — SSRF and local file read risk (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Vote tabulation - UID/email detection doesn't work when sent from external email with strict DKIM settings (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Add user configuration for navigation pinning and colour blindness mode (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Support `SafeCommittee` taint tracking (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Checks failed on Maven JLink Plugin 3.3.0 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Checks failed on Maven JLink Plugin 3.3.0 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Subscribe to pubsub for LDAP and use it to inform authorisation decisions (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Implement server-side session store to enable session revocation (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Implement server-side session store to enable session revocation (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Invalidate authorization cache and session file cache on logout/session termination (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
[I] Subscribe to pubsub for LDAP and use it to inform authorisation decisions (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Invalidate authorization cache and session file cache on logout/session termination (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Invalidate authorization cache and session file cache on logout/session termination (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Invalidate authorization cache and session file cache on logout/session termination (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Automatically close old releases in compose phase (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Checks failed on Maven JLink Plugin 3.3.0 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Invalidate authorization cache and session file cache on logout/session termination (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Add temporal validation helper to `TrustedPublisherPayload` model (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Automatically close old releases in compose phase (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Checks failed on Maven JLink Plugin 3.3.0 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
[I] Automatically close old releases in compose phase (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Apply URL encoding to distribution platform API URL parameters (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Validate JWKS URI against allowlist in GitHub OIDC flow (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Re: [I] Checks failed on Maven JLink Plugin 3.3.0 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
[I] Vote tabulation - UID/email detection doesn't work when sent from external email with strict DKIM settings (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/12
Test message
Alastair McFarlane
2026/03/12
Re: [I] SVN import URL lacks scheme validation — SSRF and local file read risk (tooling-trusted-releases)
Alastair McFarlane
2026/03/12
Re: [I] SVN import URL lacks scheme validation — SSRF and local file read risk (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [I] Replace `assert` with explicit error handling in OAuth callback (a.k.a. document no -O flag usage) (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
[PR] Adding docs for cascading (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [I] Create security documentation for authentication defense controls (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [I] Create security documentation for authentication defense controls (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [I] Treat -bin and -bin- like -src and -src- (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [I] Treat -bin and -bin- like -src and -src- (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [I] Treat -bin and -bin- like -src and -src- (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [I] Treat -bin and -bin- like -src and -src- (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [I] Should podling votes during the second phase be cc'd to the project (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [I] Should podling votes during the second phase be cc'd to the project (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [I] Treat -bin and -bin- like -src and -src- (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [I] Treat -bin and -bin- like -src and -src- (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [I] Vote result email To configuration (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [I] Add size limits to LICENSE/NOTICE file reads and remote KEYS fetch (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [I] Add size limits to LICENSE/NOTICE file reads and remote KEYS fetch (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [I] Trest -bin and -bin- like -src and -src- (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [I] Remove Referrer-Policy from server headers (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [I] Remove Referrer-Policy from server headers (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [I] Remove Referrer-Policy from server headers (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
[I] Trest -bin and -bin- like -src and -src- (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [I] Also check for null bytes (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [I] Also check for null bytes (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [I] Use extracted archives in checks rather than extracting archives again (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [I] Use extracted archives in checks rather than extracting archives again (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
[I] Remove Referrer-Policy from server headers (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [PR] Bump ldap3 from 2.10.2rc2 to 2.10.2rc3 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [PR] Bump aiosmtplib from 4.0.2 to 5.1.0 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [PR] Bump aiofiles from 24.1.0 to 25.1.0 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [PR] Bump aiofiles from 24.1.0 to 25.1.0 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [PR] Bump rich from 14.0.0 to 14.3.3 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [PR] Bump rich from 14.0.0 to 14.3.3 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [PR] Bump email-validator from 2.2.0 to 2.3.0 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [PR] Bump ldap3 from 2.10.2rc2 to 2.10.2rc3 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [PR] Bump email-validator from 2.2.0 to 2.3.0 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [PR] Bump aiosmtplib from 4.0.2 to 5.1.0 (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [I] Upload file path validation bypass when file_name parameter is provided (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [I] Upload file path validation bypass when file_name parameter is provided (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [PR] Drop `file_name` field in upload files (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [PR] Drop `file_name` field in upload files (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [I] Regular root file gets reported as directory when `targz.structure` fails (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [I] Regular root file gets reported as directory when `targz.structure` fails (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [I] Use extracted archives in checks rather than extracting archives again (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
[I] Use extracted archives in checks rather than extracting archives again (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
2026/03/11
Re: [I] SSL configuration on release-test needs work (tooling-trusted-releases)
via GitHub
Earlier messages
Later messages