I guess it's evident that all the OpenSRS dropping names are now going
to be skimmed for the quality names.

Check out the WHOIS for maxi.org (someone in a chat room mentioned this
one):

Registrant:
 PTI
 W.R.P.O.  Box 75149
 White Rock, BC V4B 5L3
 CA

 Domain Name: MAXI.ORG
 
 Administrative Contact:
    Schilling, Frank  [EMAIL PROTECTED]
    W.R.P.O.  Box 75149
    White Rock, BC V4B 5L3
    CA
    604-536-1811

 Technical Contact:
    Schilling, Frank  [EMAIL PROTECTED]
    W.R.P.O.  Box 75149
    White Rock, BC V4B 5L3
    CA
    604-536-1811

 Billing Contact:
    Schilling, Frank  [EMAIL PROTECTED]
    W.R.P.O.  Box 75149
    White Rock, BC V4B 5L3
    CA
    604-536-1811


 Record last updated on 19-Dec-2001.
 Record expires on 01-Nov-2002.
 Record Created on 01-Nov-2000.

 Domain servers in listed order:
    NS2.DIRECTSEEK.COM   216.187.118.219
    NS1.DIRECTSEEK.COM   216.187.118.218

In particular, note that it never dropped (it was expired, but directly
transferred to the new registrant).

This is going to set a *bad* precedent. What if NSI starts doing this?
This opens up a can of worms due to short-sightedness. Grrrrr. :(

What's worse is that OpenSRS/Tucows advocated a quite different
position in the discussion a few months ago. See: 

http://www.byte.org/rc-deletes/

And I quote:

"It is the recommendation of this document that Verisign Global
Registry Services (VGRS) immediately:

1. Eliminate the �batch pool� methodology and infrastructure currently
in place as an �interim� measure.
2. Reinstate the previous �first-come, first-served� re-registration
processes.
3. Require that all registrars immediately cease �batch-delete�
processes.
4. Require that all registrars adhere to the 45-day post-expiry
registered name deletion requirements of the Verisign
Registrar/Registry agreements.
5. Police denial of service and other abusive practices by registrars
as required by the Verisign/ICANN registry services agreement."

Allowing certain parties to cherry-pick the best names is hardly
consistent with the above.

Sincerely,

George Kirikos
http://www.kirikos.com/



__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Check out Yahoo! Shopping and Yahoo! Auctions for all of
your unique holiday gifts! Buy at http://shopping.yahoo.com
or bid at http://auctions.yahoo.com

Reply via email to