On Friday, June 6, 2014 9:46 PM, Brandon Long <[email protected]> wrote:
> To use DMARC, you have to be able to authenticate your > mail using either SPF or DKIM. i am. > Doing that requires running a server that does it or > using a service which does it. i am - ymail. it authenticates it's own DKIM signatures and SPF servers on my email perfectly. for free, imagine that. > There is nothing that says that YMail has to support your use case. ymail supports my use case. DMARC doesn't: it needs 3rd party support. i need nothing from ymail, they have been doing wonderful job for me 13y now. i need DMARC alignment rigidity gone. and some wise ppl to accept it. well, we may lack that, i guess. > There are those who think we must move to an authenticated sender world. > In that world, either we have a third party auth system (which we don't), > or third parties need to have the ability to provide auth (upload a dkim key, > include: for SPF). or simply we add 3rd party support to DMARC. and walla, we r there. ps. all messages to this mailing list r failing DMARC. just so u ppl know. my forwarder keeps annoying me about that. please fix it. ohhh, yes, u can't. sorry for mentioning. at least u can say receivers u don't care about DMARC, right? imagine if they didn't include DMARC-ignore in records, either. btw, i do find it ironic how messages to a mailing list about DMARC r failing the same protocol they mean to discuss. just the way world works, i guess. ppl make broken stuff, then defend them as if sky will fall if they gets fixed. pps. i'll just turn off my DMARC testing scripts... i have enough data. anybody wants to see it? actually, there's nothing to tell what i didn't say already anyways. ppps. i'm quite sure many ppl here have enough of my posts for a lifetime. so, i'll just stop replying now, as there's very little i can additionally say, beyond mocking various posters for their obvious incapability to follow my posts or whatever, which isn't my intention, interest or pleasure. i will keep in touch if u eventually fix DMARC, sure. but i predict u won't. so, farewell. -- Vlatko Salaj aka goodone http://goodone.tk _______________________________________________ dmarc mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dmarc
