On Tue, May 19, 2026, at 07:42, Douglas Foster wrote: > Assume that an intermediary contacts me, announcing his intent to forward > everything for his UserA@DomainA to my UserB@DomainB. He wants to minimize > the risk of messages being blocked by misleading credential loss, so he wants > me to accept his role as a forwarder. How do I evaluate that request?
Who is "me" in this context? As a mailbox provider, I would expect to send UserB@DomainB a message saying "UserA@DomainA wants to forward to you, click here to approve, click here to go to settings page to manage your forwarders". > My response will be, >> "Will you ensure that every forwarded message has been authenticated as free >> of impersonation? If so, then I can delegate that function to you and I >> will not have to authenticate your messages." > > If DomainA makes that promise and delivers on it, I know that his > authentication will involve a mixture of SPF, DMARC, and local policy, so it > will not be easily verified. > > I already use delegated upstream authentication to most ESP messages received > directly. I trust that they authenticate their clients so that they can get > paid, so I don't need to see a DKIM signature to believe the From address is > free of impersonation. Generalizing this approach will hit these obstacles. > • Most participants consider authentication to be a nice attribute when > present, but hardly something important enough to be required. So they > cannot make useful promises. > • Bad guys will attempt to get me to trust them even if they are not > trustworthy, and I do not know whom to trust. > ARC experience has made things more difficult because we have found > intermediaries which should have been trustworthy, but instead produce ARC > data that is incorrect and misleading. That bad experience makes any > ARC+Authorization initiative seem dubious, even if the low participation > rates could be overcome. > > Doug > > > _______________________________________________ > dmarc mailing list -- [email protected] > To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected] > -- Bron Gondwana, CEO, Fastmail Pty Ltd / Fastmail US LLC [email protected]
_______________________________________________ dmarc mailing list -- [email protected] To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]
