Hello folks,

Using tunnels vs. propagating host routes across a domain…

The former is proven to work. The latter appears to have attractive attributes 
(e.g., absence of tunneling overhead, fully distributed nature, etc.), but 
there are also aspects that need to be addressed, such as:
- Can it scale (passing host-routes for millions of nodes even in single 
operator network)?
- Can it converge fast enough for seamless handovers?
- Is it practical from charging, lawful intercept, DPI, policy enforcement 
point of view?
- How do we deal with the case when the MN moves outside the domain? (probably 
we need to fall back to using a tunnel-based solution)

The host-route-based schemes need to overcome these challenges to appear as an 
alternative to tunnel-based solutions. I'm hoping the proponents of those 
scheme will show us how they handle these issues.

Maybe it'll turn out that under certain conditions host-route-based solutions 
work just fine (Pete was pointing at local mobility). If so, we can recognize 
that and tell people they can use such solutions instead of tunnel-based 
solutions, where applicable. 

For example: If the anchor is within an operator network it can be used (which 
can substitute for tunnel-based anchoring on a central HA and also on previous 
AR -- but not for anchoring near the corresponding network which works across 
the Internet). 

...

But note that, that discussion is just about  one component of DMM solution 
set. There are other components, which are not impacted by that discussion. 
Such as:
- The MN stack treating flows differently with respect to their mobility needs 
(assigning different types [colors/anchor type, etc] of IP addresses)
- The MN stack choosing anchors (i.e., selecting a specific anchor node based 
in the anchor type selection).

…

And whenever a component involves DP/CP, we should recognize that they are 
separable and take that into account. 


Alper





_______________________________________________
dmm mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dmm

Reply via email to