In article <[email protected]> you write: >I am familiar with the contents of that blog post and the circumstances >surrounding it. My position on the usefulness of >this draft has not changed. See below for more detail.
Hi. I'm not Joe but I have a CZDS account. As I said back in August, while there are lots of zones that are delegation-mostly, that is not the same as being delegation-only. It is simply true that most TLDs are delegation-only, and this hack is not useful. I grepped through the downloaded contracted zone files for signed A and AAAA records and found over 32,000 of them in over 200 TLDs. The list of TLDs and counts are below, or you can find the whole set at https://www.iecc.com/signedglue.txt There are also _nicname._tcp SRV records in TLDs including .am .at. ax. be. bg. biz. ch. cl. co. de. dk. fo. fr. gg. hu. ie. is. and at least a dozen others. Beyond that, there are 17,000 signed MX records in the .name zone and probably other oddities if I looked further. R's, John 1 abogado.txt 1 aeg.txt 1 afamilycompany.txt 1 amazon.txt 1 aol.txt 2 arab.txt 182 asia.txt 1 audible.txt 1 author.txt 1 aws.txt 1 barefoot.txt 1 bayern.txt 1 bbc.txt 5 bbt.txt 1 beer.txt 1 bentley.txt 4 bet.txt 2 biz.txt 6 black.txt 60 blue.txt 1 bms.txt 1 book.txt 1 boston.txt 1 bot.txt 1 bradesco.txt 1 broadway.txt 8 broker.txt 2 brussels.txt 1 budapest.txt 1 buy.txt 1 call.txt 8 career.txt 1 casa.txt 17 cat.txt 8 chanel.txt 1 circle.txt 8 clubmed.txt 1 comcast.txt 1 cooking.txt 8 cookingchannel.txt 2 cpa.txt 8 crown.txt 8 crs.txt 8 csc.txt 1 cymru.txt 1 dds.txt 1 deal.txt 8 diy.txt 8 duck.txt 4 eco.txt 8 ericsson.txt 1 fashion.txt 1 fast.txt 8 fidelity.txt 1 fire.txt 1 fishing.txt 1 fit.txt 8 food.txt 8 foodnetwork.txt 8 forex.txt 1 free.txt 8 frontdoor.txt 8 fujixerox.txt 8 gallo.txt 1 garden.txt 8 genting.txt 8 glade.txt 28 global.txt 1 gop.txt 1 got.txt 2 green.txt 8 guardian.txt 8 hgtv.txt 1 horse.txt 1 hot.txt 8 hotmail.txt 8 ice.txt 1 imdb.txt 20338 info.txt 2 ist.txt 8 istanbul.txt 8 jaguar.txt 8 java.txt 1 jot.txt 1 joy.txt 8 juniper.txt 8 kerryhotels.txt 8 kerrylogistics.txt 8 kerryproperties.txt 33 kim.txt 1 kindle.txt 8 kuokgroup.txt 8 landrover.txt 1 law.txt 8 lefrak.txt 8 lego.txt 1 like.txt 8 linde.txt 6 link.txt 8 lipsy.txt 7 llc.txt 2 llp.txt 1 locus.txt 1 london.txt 8 lundbeck.txt 8 lupin.txt 1 luxe.txt 8 maif.txt 8 markets.txt 8 med.txt 1 miami.txt 8 microsoft.txt 303 mobi.txt 1 moi.txt 2 moscow.txt 8 nab.txt 8 nationwide.txt 8 next.txt 8 nextdirect.txt 8 nikon.txt 8 nissay.txt 8 norton.txt 1 now.txt 8 obi.txt 8 off.txt 8 omega.txt 3 onl.txt 8 onyourside.txt 8 oracle.txt 8 orange.txt 8171 org.txt 1 organic.txt 2 paris.txt 1 pay.txt 2 pet.txt 8 pictet.txt 1 pin.txt 14 pink.txt 4 poker.txt 4 politie.txt 1 prime.txt 1246 pro.txt 4 promo.txt 8 raid.txt 1 read.txt 8 realestate.txt 8 realtor.txt 38 red.txt 8 rexroth.txt 1 rodeo.txt 1 room.txt 8 rwe.txt 1 safe.txt 8 sanofi.txt 1 save.txt 8 sbs.txt 8 sca.txt 3 scb.txt 8 scjohnson.txt 1 secure.txt 8 sener.txt 8 ses.txt 8 shangrila.txt 8 shell.txt 1 shiksha.txt 1 silk.txt 8 sky.txt 1 smile.txt 1 spot.txt 4 srl.txt 1 surf.txt 8 swatch.txt 1 talk.txt 8 tatamotors.txt 141 tel.txt 8 tiaa.txt 8 tiffany.txt 783 top.txt 8 trading.txt 12 travel.txt 8 travelchannel.txt 1 tunes.txt 1 tushu.txt 8 ubank.txt 8 ubs.txt 8 vanguard.txt 1 vip.txt 1 virgin.txt 8 visa.txt 2 vlaanderen.txt 1 vodka.txt 8 volvo.txt 12 vote.txt 1 wales.txt 1 wanggou.txt 8 weber.txt 1 wedding.txt 8 weir.txt 8 windows.txt 1 work.txt 1 wow.txt 8 xbox.txt 8 xerox.txt 1 xfinity.txt 18 xin.txt 2 xn--30rr7y.txt 8 xn--5su34j936bgsg.txt 1 xn--6frz82g.txt 8 xn--9dbq2a.txt 3 xn--9et52u.txt 1 xn--c1avg.txt 1 xn--cckwcxetd.txt 2 xn--efvy88h.txt 1 xn--i1b6b1a6a2e.txt 1 xn--jlq480n2rg.txt 60 xn--kput3i.txt 8 xn--mk1bu44c.txt 2 xn--mxtq1m.txt 2 xn--ngbrx.txt 1 xn--nqv7f.txt 8 xn--t60b56a.txt 8 xn--tckwe.txt 8 xn--w4r85el8fhu5dnra.txt 8 xn--w4rs40l.txt 1 yamaxun.txt 1 yoga.txt 1 you.txt 1 zappos.txt _______________________________________________ DNSOP mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dnsop
