Torgny Tholerus wrote:
> Imagine that we have a second Universe, that looks exactly the same as 
> the materialistic parts of our Universe.  We may call this second 
> Universe B-Universe.  (Our Universe is A-Universe.)
> This B-Universe looks exactly the same as A-Universe.  Where there is a 
> hydrogen atom in A-Universe, there will also be a hydrogen atom in 
> B-Universe, and everywhere that there is an oxygen atom in A-Universe, 
> there will be an oxygen atom i B-universe.  The only difference between 
> A-Universe and B-Universe is that B-Universe is totally free from 
> consciousness, feelings, minds, souls, and all that kind of stuff.  The 
> only things that exist in B-Universe are atoms reacting with eachother.  
> All objects in B-Universe behave in exactly the same way as the objects 
> in A-Universe.
> The objects in B-Universe produces the same kind of sounds as we produce 
> in A-Universe, and the objects in B-Universe pushes the same buttons on 
> their computers as we do in our A-Universe.
> Questions:
> Is B-Universe possible?
> If we interview an object in B-Universe, what will that object answer, 
> if we ask it: "Are you conscious?"?
So far as I know, consciousness is some processes in (at least some) 
human brains.  Since B-universe would have brains with the same 
processes, I'd say those objects would answer, "Yes." with the same 
likelihood as in this universe - in other words I don't think there's 
any difference between the A-universe and the B-universe.

Brent Meeker

You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"Everything List" group.
To post to this group, send email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For more options, visit this group at

Reply via email to