On 1/2/2013 8:21 AM, Roger Clough wrote:
I forgot add that that's why Leibniz called this
"The best of all possible Worlds."
Why bad things happen to good people--Leibniz's Theodicy
.... As to tornadoes, there are various views, usually
part of "Theodicies". Here's the view I prefer, that of my
mentor, Leibniz, explained in his "Theodicy", which
Voltaire took up in his unfair and totally misinformed
criticism, the novel "Candide".
According to Leibniz, there are two forms of being, that
belonging to perfect, timeless, necessary reason, assigned to Heaven
or Platonia, and that of contingent, time-dependent and therefore
undependable reason and perfection (that down here, on earth).
Scientific theory deals with the former, where time is reversible,
and scientific experimentation, with the latter, done down here,
in the world, where time is not reversible.
Leibniz's view, in his theodicy , which I hold to also, is that
the world down here, that God created, is necessarily imperfect,
so, as they say "crap happens". This is because things can't be good
everywhere at the same time. Thus evil and catastrophes are
Leibniz's theodicy ior justification for God is that God, being good,
does the best that he can with the imperfect, partly evuil world
he has to work with. That is why pray for God to deliver us
from evil in the Lord's prayer. But we also say "thy will be done."
[Roger Clough], [rclo...@verizon.net <mailto:%20rclo...@verizon.net>]
"Forever is a long time, especially near the end." - Woody Allen
Ultimately, all such measures are subjective, being the result of
some arbitrary cut off here and boundary condition there. Most of all,
the effects of the finiteness of our condition cannot ever be
underestimated. One thing that Leibniz failed to comprehend is the cost
of the perfect system that he attempted to construct. Voltair saw it but
only as a weakness to lampoon Leibniz' with and not to correct, as he
and the rest of the classicists where loath to give up the Assumption of
the voyeuristic observer that can somehow see and measure all things.
Hidden in their thinking was a need to morally justify the inequality
between men that their system supported.
We live in a world of costs and scarcity. There is no such thing as
a free lunch, but if we work hard we can make a cheaper lunch. ;-)
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
"Everything List" group.
To post to this group, send email to email@example.com.
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
For more options, visit this group at