--- In FairfieldLife@yahoogroups.com, "seventhray1" <steve.sundur@...> wrote: > > What I get from this was that we have a women who had breast > cancer, was treated by Chopra at an Ayurvedic clinic, was > declared to be cured and died shortly thereafter. Is this > not the the case?
Thanks for weighing in. Obviously I have a point to make, but I want to see what Xeno thinks too. If he doesn't get to it shortly, I'll make the point in response to you. In the meantime, would you care to express an opinion about Skolnick's offer to send a copy of the woman's death certificate to anyone who asked? > It appears to me that the case he trying to make is that her > Ayurvedic treatments did not cure the cancer in spite of > claims to the contrary as evidenced by her death. For if > she had been cured of her cancer, she would not have died > within a year of being cured by her cancer, presuming the ? cause of death was cancer. > > These seem to be reasonable conclusions. What am I missing? > > --- In FairfieldLife@yahoogroups.com, "authfriend" <jstein@> wrote: > > > > --- In FairfieldLife@yahoogroups.com, "Xenophaneros Anartaxius" > anartaxius@ wrote: > > <snip> > > > As for Skolnick, I thought he approached his subject with > > > vigour and did not pull punches, but he seems to have > > > researched his attacks well. > > > > Let's just take a quick look at a bit of Skolnick's post- > > JAMA-article research efforts, as found in one of his > > early posts to alt.m.t: > > > > ----- > > From: aaskoln...@ (AASkolnick) > > Subject: Interesting Document Available > > Newsgroups: alt.meditation.transcendental > > Date: 7 Jan 1995 21:37:01 -0500 > > Message-ID: <3enj4d$b4j@ > > > > I just acquired a copy of the [Jane Doe's] death > > certificate. [Doe] appeared with Drs. Chopra and > > Lonsdorf on the Donahue Show, (the first show I think) > > and was introduced as "a former breast cancer patient." > > She claimed it was Maharishi Ayur-Veda treatments that > > cured her. She died of breast cancer on Dec. 30, 1990. > > I think the show was in 1989, but I could be mistaken. > > > > Does anyone know the date that Donahue Show was taped > > or aired? Can anyone tell me any more about Ms. > > [Doe]. She lived in Fairfield and is listed as > > having worked as a meteologist/environmental researcher, > > so I suspect she was involved with MIU. > > > > If anyone would like a copy of the death certificate, > > please message me here with fax number, postal > > address, and phone number. Please provide your name > > also. I will not respond to requests from shadowy > > lurkers and people with mythological names. -- Andrew > > Skolnick > > ----- > > > > Now, Xeno, just based on the above post, could you describe > > briefly in your own words how this woman chose to have her > > cancer treated and why it resulted in her death? > > > > Also, what do you think of Skolnick's offer to send a copy > > of her death certificate to anyone who asked for it? > > > > (Anyone else who knows nothing about this case but what I > > just posted is welcome to give it a shot as well.) > > >
