Judy I did NOT confirm that the hovering was something Richard made up! For all 
I know, he really thought that. Or maybe he just misspoke. I don't think he 
lied or trolled. All in all, I definitely think that this exchange has been the 
creation of several people, not just Richard. 





On Wednesday, January 1, 2014 2:40 PM, "[email protected]" 
<[email protected]> wrote:
 
  
Yes, maybe the angels watched, but we were really talking about human beings. 
And I've never disputed that Mary Magdalene was the first human to see the 
risen Christ according to Matthew, Mark, and John--but not Luke. So Richard was 
wrong about Luke (until he changed "see" to "realize" and pretended that's what 
he'd been saying all along). And again, there was never a disagreement about 
Mary M. having been first to see the risen Christ according to the other three 
Gospels, so Richard wasn't "right" about that if you're implying that means I 
was wrong.

I guess it's too much to expect that you would acknowledge that this whole fuss 
has been a matter of Richard's trolling and lying. But thanks at least for 
confirming that the risen Christ "hovering" was something Richard made up.

<< Having read the gospel excerpts, I even wonder if Mary M was the first to 
see the risen Christ. Maybe the angel at His tomb was the first to see Him. 


Anyway, I think you are right that risen in terms of the resurrection does not 
mean hovering. And I think Richard is right in that Mary M was the first human 
to see the risen Christ. >>




On Wednesday, January 1, 2014 1:20 PM, "authfriend@..." <authfriend@...> wrote:
 
  
As you know, she was a witness to the risen Christ, not to the resurrection 
itself. Nobody saw that.


 << what you should have put in red was that Luke wasn't at the 
>>resurrection >>
>
>
>> Neither was anybody else.
>>>
>>In the Gospel of John, Mary Magdalene "...is recorded as the first 
>witness of Jesus' resurrection (John 20:14–16); (Mark 16:9 later 
>manuscripts)."
>
>http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gospel_of_Mary


Reply via email to