On Jul 6, 2005, at 10:02 AM, David W. Fenton wrote:

It seems to me self-evident that linked parts are the way Finale 

should have been designed from the beginning. The spawing of 

individual independent files, while perhaps dictated by the realities 

of computer processing power at the time Finale was designed, make no 

sense at all when Finale is viewed as a database program. The data 

file is a database, and there are various report views for showing 

that data and subsets of that data. That is a perfectly natural way 

to think of the program and the presentation of its data.



You know, MOTU's Composer's Mosaic was designed this way, and was the reason I went with it instead of Finale in 1990.  Mosaic gave the user the ability to create as many "views" of his/her music as wanted--either scroll views or page views--and all were contained within a single file.  One could open any or all views, and then toggle between them.  You could put together a scroll view of just the woodwinds, for example.  You could have a concert score and a transposed score in the same file, and of course all of the parts, either transposed or concert.  Where MOTU dropped the ball was the fact that any change made anywhere affected everywhere else.  Tweaking the score to make it look right screwed up the parts, and vice versa.  We users had to end up creating two files--one for parts and the other for the score.  Besides that, the program was really buggy and needed a lot of work.  Unfortunately (for us Mosaic users), MOTU introduced Digital Performer at about the same time, and eventually virtually all of their R&D went into that program, and, even though we users tried to get them not to, MOTU abandoned Mosaic altogether (although they still sell it).  My report on Mosaic is still on my website:   <http://hometown.aol.com/txstnr/index11.html>  in case anyone is interested in reading it.

Lon

********************************************

Lon Price, Los Angeles

<[EMAIL PROTECTED]> <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>

<http://hometown.aol.com/txstnr/>


_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to