Seven committers voted. There were five +1 votes and no -1 votes. There was one -0.9 vote and one -0 vote.
According to the Project Charter three +1 ('yes' votes) with no -1 ('no' votes or vetoes) are needed to approve a significant code change. Therefore the proposal to merge the Temp_ComplexScripts branch into trunk has been accepted. Thank you for voting. I acknowledge that Vincent and Peter are not convinced of the wisdom of this decision. I hope we can all move forward with this new situation. Simon On Tue, Oct 25, 2011 at 10:31:43AM +0200, Simon Pepping wrote: > With his latest patch, Glenn Adams wrote: > > With this latest patch I am satisfied that there is sufficient testing and > stability in the CS branch to support its merger into trunk. Therefore, I > request that such a merge be accomplished after applying patch 5 to the CS > branch. > > ... snip ... > > Note that there remains work to be done on CS support, including adding > support for: > > - additional scripts > - additional output formats > > At present, support is provided for: > > - Arabic, Hebrew, and Devanagari Scripts > - PDF output format > > I expect that additional support for other scripts and formats will be added > over time, either by myself, or other members of the community. However, the > absence of support for all complex scripts and all output formats should not > be a deterrent to active use of the support already present. It is now a > good time to broaden the user community of the CS features, and the best way > to do that is to bring it into the trunk at this time. > > End of quote > > Following this request, I herewith propose to merge the branch > Temp_ComplexScripts into trunk, and launch a formal vote. > > I vote positive: +1 > > For the rules of voting about code commits, see the project charter, > article 11, http://wiki.apache.org/xmlgraphics/ProjectCharter. > > Simon Pepping