Hi Michael I see your what you mean by saying that the Adobe TCS being analogous to the Frame/WebWorks combination. It overcomes FrameMaker's limitations through the use of a non-integrated, third party enhancement, in this case RoboHelp, for multi-channel output. RoboHelp now uses FrameMaker files much in the same manner as it uses Word files.
I cannot really say that round-tripping is what I am looking for. What I would really like to see a fully integrated authoring environment that integrates multi-channel output with a powerful editor that overcomes FrameMaker's many limitations, thus obviating the need for import and export. AuthorIT does this with some limitations, and Blaze (still vaporware) promises to provide such functionality. My question then becomes: Why should I purchase the TCS bundle if all it offers is a WebWorks replacement? RoboHelp is a full featured HAT with printed output (PDF) support. Why not just import my legacy Frame documents into RoboHelp, and then use RoboHelp as my authoring environment? Regards, Richard Levine -----Original Message----- From: Michael M?ller-Hillebrand [mailto:m...@cap-studio.de] Sent: Wednesday, September 26, 2007 10:55 AM To: Richard Levine Subject: Re: Adobe Unveils Technical Communication Suite Hi Richard, I'd like to understand what you exactly mean with two-way round- tripping and why you need that. I always thought of "multi-channel publishing" as "single-source publishing" with a stress on "single" and having easy production paths into PDF and Online Help. Therefore the only thing (I thought) I need is a live connect to the source documents. Why would I want to make changes in the originals during the Online Help production phase? Thanks, - Michael M?ller-Hillebrand Am 25.09.2007 um 21:54 schrieb Richard Levine: > Hi Michael, > > You make a good point. I am looking forward to testing this when the > trial version is ready. It would be nice if there was two way round- > tripping such as that offered by Flare. > > Richard Levine > > -----Original Message----- > From: framers-bounces+techsoft=netvision.net.il at lists.frameusers.com > [mailto:framers-bounces > +techsoft=netvision.net.il at lists.frameusers.com] On > Behalf Of Michael M?ller-Hillebrand > Sent: Tuesday, September 25, 2007 7:30 PM > To: Framers; framers at omsys.com > Subject: Re: Adobe Unveils Technical Communication Suite > > Am 25.09.2007 um 16:41 schrieb Richard Levine: > >> According to Adobe's web site, RH 7 "integration" is one-way .fm or >> .mif file import. If this is true, it is not integration in my book. > > No, it's more than that. > > It is a connection to the original FrameMaker book or document very > much like good ol' WebWorks Publisher provided it. If you change your > FrameMaker documents, this will be reflected in your RoboHelp output, > if you want so. > But you can do local changes, if you like breaking your single-source > workflow. > > Check it out! Very much like I couldn't believe we would see > FrameMaker with Unicode I was surprised to see that level of > integration with RoboHelp. > > - Michael M?ller-Hillebrand -- _____________________________________________________________ Michael M?ller-Hillebrand -- Tel. +49 (9131) 28747 Adobe Certified Expert, FrameMaker 7 L?sungen und Training, FrameScript, XML/XSL, Unicode ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~ Auch dieses Jahr wieder auf der tekom-Tagung in Wiesbaden ~ ~ Messestand F20 im Foyer: Pers. Beratung vom 7.-9.11.2007 ~ ~ Besuchen Sie mein Tutorial: ?Frame-Doktor? (9.11. 8:45h) ~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~