On Sat, Oct 3, 2026 at 6:51 PM Gregory Pietsch via Freedos-devel
<[email protected]> wrote:
>
> The students are too lazy to look up the history of the FreeDOS
> Project? I would think that they have done book reports in the past. It's
> not like we're a secret cabal or anything. -- Gregory


The "FreeDOS history" thing was just a demo I did in class, because I
wanted to pick an example that they weren't familiar with, but I was.

I showed the history and asked "does that look good to you? If you had
been asked to write a short history of the FreeDOS Project, but didn't
want to do the research, could you use that?" And about half the
students said "yeah, that looks okay to me, I'd probably use that if I
wanted to use AI to do it for me."

Then I picked it apart and showed that AI got the overall story
correct, but got small details wrong. That's a common "miss" with AI.


I also do another class demo where I ask AI to summarize the first
'Star Wars' (1977) movie from the perspective of someone who had never
watched any of the movies or shows, or read any of the books or
comics, so it was their very first time watching 'Star Wars.'
Summarize the movie and list the major characters.

Last year, AI listed Yoda and Lando (both introduced in 'Empire
Strikes Back'). This year, we only got characters from 'Star Wars'
(1977) but you get names like Princess Leia Organa (last name never
mentioned in the movie) and Darth Vader "Dark Lord of the Sith"
('Sith' not mentioned on screen until Episode 1, 1999), and Grand Moff
Tarkin (only referred to as "Governor Tarkin" in the movie) and Wedge
Antilles (last name never mentioned on screen until a 'Star Wars
Rebels' episode in 2016). All technically correct, but *wrong* in that
these extra details would not have been known by someone who had never
seen anything from Star Wars before. But AI can't help itself from
adding the extra details because it was trained on everything,
including comics and books and movies and shows.


I used those class demos to "justify" to the students why their big AI
assignment asked them to verify all of the citations that AI gave
them. Check the date, check the authors, click all of the links,
everything. For example, some "DOI" URLs (generated by Copilot)
pointed only to a Bing search, not to an article. (And if you
copied/pasted the URL into your browser, you got "not found.")


_______________________________________________
Freedos-devel mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/freedos-devel

Reply via email to