On Sat, Oct 3, 2026 at 5:01 PM Jim Hall via Freedos-devel
<[email protected]> wrote:
>
> For code, I have several concerns:
>
> 1. The provenance [place of origin, history] is lost when you use AI
> to write code for you. This is significant because AI tends to repeat
> its training data.
>
>
> This isn't a made-up theoretical example. For example, the US
> Copyright Office notes that “Generative AI models sometimes output
> material that replicates or closely resembles copyrighted works” and
> “Such outputs likely infringe the reproduction right and, to the
> extent they adapt the originals, the right to prepare derivative
> works.” (Copyright and Artificial Intelligence Part 3: Generative AI
> Training. United States Copyright Office. May 2025 report, p 31.)
>
> Here's where that matters: If you're using AI to write some code for
> you, did that chunk of code replicate someone else's code? For a small
> contribution (a few lines) that may not be much of a concern; there
> are only so many ways to open a file and read it.

You have this problem of provenance with humans too.  Yet, there are
no controls for that.  What if someone takes code straight out of a
book or copyrighted reference document.  Why is provenance an issue
for AI-assisted code versus other aids?    Copyright (as in Oracle vs.
Google) does not concern itself with the significance of the
contribution; only that the copier did not have license to copy the
material.

[SNIP]
>
> 2. At least in the US, the courts and US Copyright Office have held
> that the more you use AI to make a thing, the less strong your claim
> on copyright.
[SNIP]
>
> If you vide coded a compiler by feeding AI the C Programming Language
> specification, and directed AI to create test cases based on that spec
> and to create code that addressed gaps and issues, I'd say you've used
> AI to the point that you can't claim copyright. And that means you
> can't say "this is GNU GPL" or "this is MIT" or any other license,
> because you need copyright to claim a license.
>

If you believe such works aren't copyrightable, then what are they?
If you believe they are derived from copyrighted works, then what are
these combined works?  A human didn't assemble/derive them.  Therefore
a human didn't violate copyright.   Are they magically copyright free
or uncopyrightable?

[SNIP]


_______________________________________________
Freedos-devel mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/freedos-devel

Reply via email to