On 10/3/2026 8:02 PM, Louis Santillan via Freedos-devel wrote:
You have this problem of provenance with humans too. Yet, there are
no controls for that. What if someone takes code straight out of a
book or copyrighted reference document. Why is provenance an issue
for AI-assisted code versus other aids? Copyright (as in Oracle vs.
Google) does not concern itself with the significance of the
contribution; only that the copier did not have license to copy the
material.
In case of a human doing this, it is intentional deception. And
ultimately just as deplorable as AI generated code that doesn't give any
hints as to where its answer came from.
Ignorance is not always bliss...
If you believe such works aren't copyrightable, then what are they?
If you believe they are derived from copyrighted works, then what are
these combined works? A human didn't assemble/derive them. Therefore
a human didn't violate copyright. Are they magically copyright free
or uncopyrightable?
Sorry Louis, but you can't seriously be that ignorant. Yes, a human does
violate the copyright if (s)he publishes AI generated code that
(unknowingly, perhaps) is based on previously copyrighted material.
The method of acquisition changes, not the intend to deceit...
Ralf
_______________________________________________
Freedos-devel mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/freedos-devel