Hi,

The debate gets interesting.


El dom, 4 oct 2026 a las 5:03, Louis Santillan via Freedos-devel (<
[email protected]>) escribió:

> On Sat, Oct 3, 2026 at 5:01 PM Jim Hall via Freedos-devel
> <[email protected]> wrote:
> >
> > For code, I have several concerns:
>

Thanks, it clarifies me, the concerns are about the legal issues, not that
the AI makes mistakes.


> > Here's where that matters: If you're using AI to write some code for
> > you, did that chunk of code replicate someone else's code? For a small
> > contribution (a few lines) that may not be much of a concern; there
> > are only so many ways to open a file and read it.
>
> You have this problem of provenance with humans too.  Yet, there are
> no controls for that.  What if someone takes code straight out of a
> book or copyrighted reference document.  Why is provenance an issue
> for AI-assisted code versus other aids?    Copyright (as in Oracle vs.
> Google) does not concern itself with the significance of the
> contribution; only that the copier did not have license to copy the
> material.
>

Well, there are two ways of regarding the AI:
* As a sophisticated search engine, in which case, you are right, it is the
human that decides to ship that code who is responsible.
* However, the AI we are talking about is GenAI, in the sense that it
"produces" something that did not exist (from sources than did). This
brings to my mind that clause about generated code in GPL 3, I seem to
remember that GPL licensing is only contagious if the resulting code has
bits of the original source.
I'm not a lawyer here, but in that circumstance, what is the license of the
produced code, when no parts of the producing machine are reproduced? (This
problem existed before AI).
And now take it to the AI world, which I guess is what Jim says that the
more you use the AI, the less you hold copyright on it.

I believe Ralf's example gives another use case for AI that I assume would
be still compatible: use AI to learn. "Write an algorithm to perform such
or such task", you learn, then you write your own.

Aitor
_______________________________________________
Freedos-devel mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/freedos-devel

Reply via email to