First, copyright laws are a complete and utter mess regarding software. Second, 
they are not the only laws to consider.

Let’s say you read a copyrighted book on sorting algorithms. A few months 
later, you sit down and write a program that implements a QSORT algorithm. You 
as a human were “trained” on that code which was under copyright. You may or 
may not write (more or less) the same code that was Copyrighted in that book. 
You may not even be aware that you did it. (Let us not forget all of the 
concern over possible contamination of open source DOS programming, if you had 
ever seen the leaked MS-DOS source code.) 

But, where does that chain end? If you looked at a GPLv3 program years ago 
which performed a Bubble sort. And now you write one, it could be more or less 
identical. 

As a whole, programs can be very unique. But, if you are striving to achieve 
the best way to perform a specific part of a program, there are only so many 
ways to efficiently accomplish that task. Statistically, those pieces will end 
up being nearly identical end the end. 

This is why a lot of small pieces of code to perform various tasks are not 
individually considered as being Copyrighted themselves and are more along the 
lines of “this is how this is done” and are Public Knowledge. 
Like…Print(‘Hello, World!’). And even more complex things like QSORT. 

All of this brings up the question: how much difference is there (or should 
there be) between a human trained on various sources, from those under full 
Copyright to ones in the Public Domain, compared to an AI trained on similar 
materials?

But, as I said earlier, there are even more legal considerations. After all, 
there are these little things called Patents, which seem to be rarely discussed 
in the OS community. Just because you may be able to create a truly unique 
piece of code to perform some task, you may be safe from a copyright violation. 
But, the idea itself can be patented. Thereby, giving you no legal right to 
distribute it.

:-)

Jerome


_______________________________________________
Freedos-devel mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/freedos-devel

Reply via email to