>> Unless you have really old stacks your device will pick the new GUA first to 
>> talk to your jukebox when you are on your neighbor's network and the ULA to  
>> talk to it when you are on your own.

> No, it won't. It will pick GUA->GUA both times.

> Per the table in http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc6724#section-2.1 it will pick 
> the GUA as a destination address, and per Rule 6, it will choose the GUA to 
> connect to it.

> Which means that if you *want* to force it to use ULA inside the network and 
> GUA outside, the only scalable option is to use split-tunnel DNS. You could 
> change the policy table too, but most users won't, unless the standards 
> change, and major OSes change the policy tables.

No, the RFC 6724 rules are recommended *default* rules. The authors of that RFC 
did an excellent job at making that clear. IMO, users (who know how) should be 
free to change the default rules in their devices if they don't like those 
rules. Application developers are free to implement whatever rules make sense 
for their applications. I've been involved with applications where the default 
rules would have caused increased complexity in application design, so rules 
that made sense for that app were used instead. 
_______________________________________________
homenet mailing list
homenet@ietf.org
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/homenet

Reply via email to