I would strongly disagree. From what you've described, it would have to yield 
an emergent property. In other words, something that is more than the sum of 
its parts. 

I don't believe that can exist in the human mind. 

As far as rational understanding reaching limits - well that's a fact of life. 
Given infinite time, we can understand infinitely. But, we live in a finite 
world with finite time. However, that doesn't mean that it is useless or 
futile, or that it doesn't help us reach better levels of proficiency. 

I remember someone saying once that what else is there? What better way do we 
have of understanding and learning about something other than rational thought 
and scientific inquiry? We'll never know everything, but no other method of 
uncovering knowledge has given us as much or taken us as far.

To put it another way, suppose a student asks you what it takes to be musical. 
Are you going to give an explanation as if you are talking about alchemy (well 
you need to transmute this lead bar...), say that they must find it within 
themselves (kind of a Zen Bhuddist way), or give them a systematic way to 
actually play musically? 

-William



Well put.  What makes many human pursuits (horn playing among others) so 

fascinating  is that they resist complete analysis.  Even the expert referred 
to 

in Bob's apt quotation will not be able to competely analyze even the few 

possibilities that are known to the expert.  Because music making is an amalgam 

of physical and mental skill and emotional intelligence, multiplied by the 

players performing and the listening audience, rational analysis will ALWAYS 

reach limits of understanding, no matter what tools (MRI, for example) we might 

subect it to.



Tom Reicher



 


_______________________________________________
post: [email protected]
unsubscribe or set options at 
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org

Reply via email to