2014-10-17 17:01 keltezéssel, Hans-Peter Diettrich írta:
> Michael Schnell schrieb:
>> On 10/17/2014 12:16 PM, Mattias Gaertner wrote:
>>> Googling gives lot of pages saying that cannot is more formal than
>>> can't.
>> IMHO, Open Source projects are not supposed to be "formal" in that way.
>>
>> I always find it repellent when some software in German uses the
>> formal "Sie" instead of the familiar/colloquial "Du"
> 
> I don't like both :-(
> 
> In German documentation I'd avoid to address the reader, as far as
> possible. This also eliminates the problem of sex, in any language,
> where anti-discrimination and political correctness <shudder> requires
> the mention both males and females.

I agree with Hans-Peter! :)

In Hungarian there are four(!) form of addressing the partner in a
communication:
1. Önözés: "Ön"
        - mostly in official communications
        - talking to the second person as she/he was the third person
2. Magázás: "Maga"
        - between foreign persons and sometimes between child and parent
        - talking to the second person as she/he was the third person
3. Tegezés: "Te"
        - in friendly and/or familiar relations
        - talking to the second person as a friend
4. Tetszikezés:
        - young person talking to an old person
        - using the word "tetszik" near to the important verb or
        infinitive-participle

For example the followings are the same in English ("Do you want to
delete this file?"):
        "Ön törölni akarja e fájlt?"
        "Maga törölni akarja e fájlt?"
        "Törölni akarod e fájlt?" = "Te törölni akarod e fájlt?"
        "Törlni tetszik e fájlt?"
But "Törölni akarja e fájlt?" means that "Does she/he want to delete
this file?"

To avoid problems, when I am translating a text like "Do you want to
delete this file?" I prefer something like this :
        "E fájl tölése?" = "Deleting this file?"

It is very hard to figure out that who is on the other side in a
communication if she/he is not by your side physically (for example
reading the messages showing up in your software)...

-- 
Péter Gábor
[email protected]

--
_______________________________________________
Lazarus mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.lazarus.freepascal.org/mailman/listinfo/lazarus

Reply via email to