Hi Karl,

> Instead of using templates, I create skeleton files with mknew.pl [1].

To be clear, the complexity and technicality of what you’ve described — using 
git, having makefiles, touching the command line, etc. — is what I would hope a 
great framework would avoid. (And some of those mentioned in this thread 
attempt to do exactly that.)

In my experience (including trying to mentor very intelligent composer 
colleagues on Lilypond, and teaching Lilypond workshops to college students), 
the basic Lilypond user wants to say something like:

%%%
\include “SATB_framework.ily”

soprano = { blah }
alto = { blah }
tenor = { blah }
bass = { blah }

\makeScore #’(soprano, alto, tenor, bass)
%%%

and have a beautiful SATB score pop out.

Cheers,
Kieren.
__________________________________________________

My work day may look different than your work day. Please do not feel obligated 
to read or respond to this email outside of your normal working hours.


Reply via email to