Just to add on to what Gary wrote about the Vickey Heller post:

All of the units that she displayed where for studios and 1 bedroom
apartments.  The landlords would not rent these units to families with
children.

I think we have to keep this argument to facts (like Gary is doing in his
post) and not a mix of ideology and facts (like Vickey is doing in her
post).

In my experience the policy issues affordable housing have been:

1.  supply
2.  production
3.  market forces
4.  preservation

Most of the crossfire and ideological mudslinging comes from people who
are *housing providers* (supply) ( I'll even grant *affordable*housing
providers) who operate in one portion of the housing market and use the
factors and assumptions in their specific area to critique  proposals or
practices in other portions of the housing market--production.

This is a dangerous practice because the market operates differently in
the various housing sectors.  Financing, zoning, public policy, and
regulation operate differently.  To assume that they are the same creates
confusion and resentment.

To restate my position: The housing market is made up of several different
segments and to argue that there is no affordable housing crisis because
the Sunday paper lists a lot of 1 bedroom and studio apartments for the
single individual or couple market misses the point.

David Wilson
Loring Park




_______________________________________
Minneapolis Issues Forum - A Civil City Civic Discussion - Mn E-Democracy
Post messages to: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subscribe, Unsubscribe, Digest option, and more:
http://e-democracy.org/mpls

Reply via email to