On Thursday 16 December 2010 14:04:09 Narendra Sisodiya wrote: > On Thu, Dec 16, 2010 at 1:51 PM, jtd <[email protected]> wrote: > > On Wednesday 15 December 2010 21:49:48 Narendra Sisodiya wrote: > > > INAL. TINLA. > > > > > > Well, is this my first article against Creative Commons > > > License. actually not. I am not against any license scheme. I > > > want to express in this article is creative commons and > > > anyother license is not made for you - (the normal public). > > > There are better license exist which can help you for creative > > > a better world. > > > Lets us first discuss some of the things. > > > > > > *For whom this article made for* > > > * *This article is made for user who have small > > > understanding over license and other similar thing. > > > > While I commiserate with you on the legalise in various licences, > > I would strongly recommend anyone creating copyrighted works to > > read copyright law and licences sufficiently to be able to use > > some of them for their own works. It is mandatory, more so if you > > intend to create your own licence. > > > > Ignorance of law is a very weak defence and a disaster in attack. > > > > The newspapers in Mumbai carried an article on a C spat in Mumbai > > HC, between the claimed inheritors of the scripts of "Jaane Bhi > > Do Yaro" and the claimed holders of the copyright. 17 years after > > the script writer died and 25 years after the serial stopped. > > > > There have been similiar spats between Naushad Ali the music > > director and the erstwhile HMV/Gramaphone Company of India. Afaik > > it was about those ghastly remixes. > > > > Without sitting with a copyright law team, that has a good > > understanding of copyleft principals, trying to forge a licence > > is pointless. > > My sole purpose was to have discussion. May you direct me some 2-3 > guys which whom I can sit and discuss.
I understand that this was intended as a discussion - it still hasnt erupted into flames. But discussing creation of a new licence requires interaction with a legal team alongwith the community. All the other licences have had this interaction. You would first have to check out all the others, pinpoint the defeciencies and your missing needs, then proceed to this discussion. You might have gauged that a new licence is a bigger can of worms than the existing licences. Refer to the 3 year long rukus over GPL V3. -- Rgds JTD _______________________________________________ network mailing list [email protected] http://lists.fosscom.in/listinfo.cgi/network-fosscom.in
