Hi Fred - interspersed:

Shel 


> [Original Message]
> From: Fred 

> However, on my new DS, I have found that the entire 4-way switch assembly
> is not exactly the finest design in user-interface engineering.  

I think the design is OK, not great, but OK.  The implementation seems a
little tacky - kind of loose, not a real solid feel to it.

> For both
> the left-right-up-down functioning and the OK functioning, pressing the
> button (or the appropriate edge of the 4-way switch) does ~not~ always
> result in the intended action.  I have found that I have to be a little
> more deliberate.

Maybe I'm used to being more deliberate as I've worked with the little Sony
for a while.  It has a similar switch, which feels a lot more solid, but
which works in a similar, but not identical, fashion.

>
> In the case of the OK button, for example, I have found that pressing the
> OK button with the flesh of my fingertip (even if I always feel the soft
> "ka-plunk", as the button more-or-less hits bottom) does ~not~ always
> result in the OK action being "heard" by the camera's circuitry.  However,
> I have found that, if I poke the OK button and press it down with my
> fingernail, I always have success.

The fingernail approach works best for me as well.  

> I am curious - do any other DS users notice any "tackiness" in these
> controls?  And, how about the *ist D?

Yes ... similar controls on the Sony, my only real point of comparison,
feel a lot better.


Shel


Reply via email to